Abigail Shrier has written the first book-length study of a fascinating phenomenon, yet it has been widely ignored
WASHINGTON, DC
A TEENAGE GIRL who decides to alter her body so that it resembles a boys commits herself to a lifetime of medical treatments. Top surgerya double mastectomyis a major operation. She must take regular, large doses of testosterone. This may increase her chance of developing heart problems. It also causes the uterus to atrophy, often painfully, which may necessitate a hysterectomy.
Some of the changes to her body will be irreversible, and likely to cause distress if she changes her mind. If she has taken puberty-blockers as well as testosterone she may well be infertile. Only a few months of testosterone may have altered her voice and given her a lifelong five oclock shadow. Fortunately for such girls, bottom surgerya phalloplastyis so often problematic that few request it.
All this, coupled with the fact that adolescence is confusing at the best of times, might suggest that teenagers should, by and large, be discouraged from embarking on biomedical gender reassignment. That is the argument running through Irreversible Damage, a book by Abigail Shrier, a journalist. It is not one that holds much sway in America. As the number of transgender clinics has grown from one in 2007 to at least 50 today, so has the number of young patients in them. Once they were mostly boys; today they are girls. Ms Shrier argues that many are victims of an ideology which holds that the feeling of being in the wrong body must be affirmed at all costs. It has fuelled a craze, she writes, to which teenage girls are particularly susceptible.
Irreversible Damage is full of stories from the mostly white, privileged world in which this seems to have flourished. Teenagers, often awkward and anxious, who have lost themselves in an online world that lionises anyone who identifies as trans. YouTubers, who extol the glories of testosterone as if it were a protein shake and dismiss parents who are sceptical of trans-identification as toxic. Teachers, who do not tell parents that their child is going by a different name at school. The group she reports on in greatest detail is parents. Many of them come across as hapless. Apparently unable to tell their children that feelings of pain and confusion, especially in adolescence, are part of life and usually pass, they instead hope therapists will sort everything out.
Ms Shrier is damning of some of the professionals who have built careers working with trans-identifying children. She points out that this is the only medical field apart from cosmetic surgery in which both diagnosis and treatment are determined by the patient. She describes doctors and therapists (who would ordinarily consider it their job to challenge their patients assumptions) bowing to the judgment of vulnerable teenagers. They also, grievously, tell parents who do not accept that their daughters are boys that failing to affirm their identity may heighten the risk of suicide (research does not back this up).
Data on transgender medical interventions are poorno one knows how many teenagers have transitionedand one wonders at times if Ms Shrier may have become so steeped in the phenomenon that she exaggerates its reach. But she tells the stories of those she interviews with great care. She writes empathetically about the distress of gender dysphoria, the relentless chafe of a body that feels all wrong, and the experience of adults who have transitioned (a group that has long suffered discrimination). She quotes her interviewees at such length that it would be hard to claim she has misrepresented them.
Yet despite this the book has been denounced as transphobic. This month, a prominent lawyer from the American Civil Liberties Union tweeted, from his personal account, that stopping the circulation of this book and these ideas is 100% a hill I will die on. A professor of English literature at Berkeley suggested that people should steal the book and burn it. Few mainstream newspapers have reviewed it, though it is one of the first accessible treatments of a subject that has generated much fascinated coverage.
This is a clear illustration of what the book claims: the dominance of an ideology that brooks no dissent or debate. One of the most shocking episodes it describes concerns Lisa Littman, a medical doctor and researcher at Brown University, who noted in a paper in 2018 that most transgender children were teenage girls with no history of gender dysphoria. Many of the teenagers in her study had been exposed to peers who had come out as trans shortly before doing so themselves; a majority had spent more time on the internet. The study sparked a bullying campaign, which prompted Brown to publish an apology, though the papers findings never changed. She was fired from another job as a consultant.
In Irreversible Damage Ms Shrier describes meeting Dr Littman and wondering out loud about the cultural factors that might be causing so many American girls to want to become boys. She is impressed when Dr Littman refuses to theorise beyond the limits of her data. This punctilious respect for the facts had threatened to destroy her career.
This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline "Miss gender"
Read the original post:
A book on transitioning girls is denounced as transphobic - The Economist
- Low T Center bringing innovative testosterone treatment for men to Nevada with new Center in Las Vegas - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Testosterone doesn't boost functioning in older men - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- FDA staff concerned about safety of Endo's testosterone injection - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Panel divided over safety of Endo's testosterone drug - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- International Study Confirms Low Testosterone in 84 Percent of Lung Cancer Patients Taking Crizotinib - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Dr. Dan Engle on Onnit's T+ Testosterone Supplement - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Myths About Testosterone (w/Emery) - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- FTM Jaycob: 1 Month on Testosterone - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- 41 Weeks on Testosterone - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- What Is The Best Testosterone Booster? - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- 9 months on testosterone - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Can Excess Testosterone Levels Cause Man Boobs AKA Gynecomastia - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Ninth Shot of Testosterone - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- 11 months on testosterone - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Whats Better, Gels or Shots? (Testosterone Replacement Therapy) - Video - April 29th, 2013 [April 29th, 2013]
- Increase testosterone:Sleep In A Cold, Dark Room - Video - May 3rd, 2013 [May 3rd, 2013]
- Testosterone for Men - Video - May 3rd, 2013 [May 3rd, 2013]
- 'Shootout At Wadala': Out and out testosterone-driven gangster flick (Hindi Film Review) - May 4th, 2013 [May 4th, 2013]
- Tenth Shot of Testosterone (+ series recap) - Video - May 4th, 2013 [May 4th, 2013]
- Fourteen Weeks on Testosterone - Video - May 4th, 2013 [May 4th, 2013]
- BPA Linked with Lower Testosterone - May 8th, 2013 [May 8th, 2013]
- Fatherhood leads to a drop in testosterone, study finds - May 8th, 2013 [May 8th, 2013]
- 19 Weeks on Testosterone - Video - May 8th, 2013 [May 8th, 2013]
- Bush - Testosterone - Video - May 8th, 2013 [May 8th, 2013]
- 1 year - May 8th, 2013 [May 8th, 2013]
- FTM Emery 1 Year on Testosterone - Video - May 8th, 2013 [May 8th, 2013]
- 1year7months21days on testosterone - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- Fifteen Weeks on Testosterone - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- FTM Kris First day on testosterone - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- FTM: Introduction Testosterone Day 1 - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- 1 Year 6 Months of Testosterone, 2 Months Post-Op Top Surgery - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- INCREASE TESTOSTERONE - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- Testosterone Supplements: Best Test Supplement Reviews! - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- First Shot of Testosterone - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- BUSH - Testosterone - LIVE - Atlantic City - 5/4/13 - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- Testosterone Booster: Best Test Booster Review! - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- How to Increase Testosterone? My Stories! - Video - May 9th, 2013 [May 9th, 2013]
- Testosterone Supplements May Hurt Male Fertility, Study Finds - May 11th, 2013 [May 11th, 2013]
- Ten month on testosterone FTM update. - Video - May 11th, 2013 [May 11th, 2013]
- Dysphoria on Testosterone - Video - May 11th, 2013 [May 11th, 2013]
- Radiation From Cell Phones Lowers Testosterone? - Video - May 12th, 2013 [May 12th, 2013]
- t testosterone booster get your day started review - Video - May 12th, 2013 [May 12th, 2013]
- Testosterone - Expectations and Desires - Video - May 12th, 2013 [May 12th, 2013]
- Troxyphen testosterone booster (first look) - Video - May 12th, 2013 [May 12th, 2013]
- 4 Months 2 weeks on Testosterone/ cali update - Video - May 12th, 2013 [May 12th, 2013]
- Pro Testosterone Review. Restore Your Youthful Energy And Muscular Body With Pro Testosterone! - Video - May 13th, 2013 [May 13th, 2013]
- Testosterone: Three Months. - Video - May 13th, 2013 [May 13th, 2013]
- Heavy Overdoses on Testosterone - Video - May 13th, 2013 [May 13th, 2013]
- Bush "Testosterone," "Machinehead" (The Rave/Eagles Club, Milwaukee, WI, 5/8/2013) - Video - May 13th, 2013 [May 13th, 2013]
- "OSS-TEST" Number #1 Natural Testosterone Booster Testimonial Review - Video - May 13th, 2013 [May 13th, 2013]
- Testosterone Replacement Therapy Aside, Luke Rockhold's Focus Needs to Shift to UFC on FX 8 - May 15th, 2013 [May 15th, 2013]
- Male testosterone levels increase when victorious in competition against rivals, but not friends - May 15th, 2013 [May 15th, 2013]
- Tommy Testosterone working at Ed Reyes' place - Video - May 15th, 2013 [May 15th, 2013]
- Ask Dr. Bob: Testosterone, Dry Eyes - May 15th, 2013 [May 15th, 2013]
- Testosterone Levels Fluctuate During Sporting Events, Competitions - May 16th, 2013 [May 16th, 2013]
- Male testosterone levels increase after winning competition with rivals, but not friends - May 16th, 2013 [May 16th, 2013]
- How to Pronounce Testosterone - Video - May 16th, 2013 [May 16th, 2013]
- Study: Even in dominoes, testosterone a factor - May 17th, 2013 [May 17th, 2013]
- High-testosterone competitors more likely to choose red - May 17th, 2013 [May 17th, 2013]
- 16 Weeks on Testosterone - Video - May 17th, 2013 [May 17th, 2013]
- Higher testosterone, vegans or carnivores - Video - May 17th, 2013 [May 17th, 2013]
- Men's testosterone soars when their team wins, similar to war - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- The TRUTH About Natural Testosterone Boosters - Video - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- 4 months 3 weeks on Testosterone - Video - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- 2 months on testosterone - Video - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- Testosterone booster review. Testosterone booster Facts - Video - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- AUA13: PCa Risk Not Elevated with Testosterone Replacement - Video - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- Testosterone Side Effects Boynton Beach Florida - Video - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- 1 year on testosterone - May 20th, 2013 [May 20th, 2013]
- Testosterone Replacement Therapy: Nothing To Be Ashamed Of: Strike First Nutrition - Video - May 20th, 2013 [May 20th, 2013]
- Warning: Avoid open flames if using testosterone gels - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- Testosterone Therapy Medical Seminar; The Truth About Testosterone and Testosterone Therapy - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- Male Testosterone Levels Increase with Win Against Rivals but Not Friends - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- FTM Kris 2nd shot of testosterone - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- 1 Year On Testosterone Replacement Therapy (Whats Changed + My Future On T) - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- Testosterone Treatment For Men With Type 2 Diabetes - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- 3 Years on Low-Dose Testosterone - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- Kevin McClain: 6 Months on Testosterone - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- Testosterone and the Cardiovascular System: Friend or Foe? - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]
- FTM Vlog 33) 5 Weeks on Testosterone...moody hairy man-beast! - Video - May 21st, 2013 [May 21st, 2013]