Illustration by cristina span/for the boston globe
The Greeks asked their oracles to predict future fortunes and future losses. The Romans studied the entrails of sacrificed animals for similar reasons. In modern-day medicine, though, soothsayers come in the form of genetic tests.
Ever since the human genome was sequenced almost 15 years ago, tens of thousands of genetic tests have flooded the marketplace. By analyzing someones DNA, often through a blood sample or cheek swab, these tests promise to foretell whether a patient is prone to certain cancers, blessed with the potential to become a star soccer player, or at an elevated risk of having an opioid addiction.
Advertisement
These types of genetic tests are finding an eager audience. The North American genetic testing market, already the largest in the world, was worth $11.9 billion in 2016, by one estimate, and is expected to grow at more than 15 percent a year for the foreseeable future. Companies such as LabCorp, which offer genetic tests via doctor recommendations, and the healthcare giant Roche have moved aggressively into the field. The company 23andMe, a household name because of its ancestry tests, sells health-related tests directly to consumers.
But for a source of medical information to be legally sold in the United States, just how accurate does it need to be?
Like a prediction from a crystal ball, genetic test results are sometimes wrong. Some tests that predict the likelihood a young pregnant woman will have a child with a genetic condition such as Down syndrome may only be correct only 60 percent of the time. Most genetic tests, and many other lab tests, go unvetted by the Food and Drug Administration. That means these tests may not undergo any independent review to make sure they accurately pick up the disease or genetic conditions they claim to be seeking.
Using the worlds first portable DNA lab to sequence beer is a cool thing to do.
The FDA has been wrestling for years with whether and how to do more. During the Obama administration, the agency proposed a new set of draft limits on a whole class of tests, and then put them on hold immediately after Donald Trumps election. This spring, the FDA gave 23andMe permission to market genetic screenings for susceptibility to Alzheimers, Parkinsons, and other conditions. It was the first time the agency blessed direct-to-consumer tests for genetic health risks.
While the debate over genetic testing often follows a pattern familiar from countless other industries business groups want less regulation, and consumer advocates favor more it also raises more cosmic questions: Is a medical test just a piece of information? Or is it something more, if its result leads to dramatic or irreversible action such as chemotherapy or an abortion? And if a data point is factually suspect, or ripe for misinterpretation, when and how should it be offered to consumers?
Advertisement
Especially if regulators stand aside, Americans may soon be swimming in even more tests that vary greatly in their reliability. Yet for some people contemplating a current ailment or their future well-being, getting an answer even an unreliable one may be better than no answer at all.
Especially for people expecting a baby, genetic tests can be hard to resist. I think we all are wanting to know our child doesnt have something... we want them to be healthy, said Mischa Livingstone, a filmmaker and professor who lives in California. Without asking for it, his pregnant wife, Jessica, was given a genetic test that predicted a 99 percent chance their child would have Turner syndrome, a genetic condition that can lead to short stature, heart defects, and other symptoms. But genetic tests for Turner are more often wrong than right a fact the couple didnt know at the time.
They were devastated, and immediately went for more invasive testing, which showed the fetus was fine. But their sense of dread didnt lift until their daughter, now 2 1/2, was born perfectly healthy.
Despite the heartache a faulty genetic test result caused, Livingstone says hed consider asking for one again. I think it feeds into that need for certainty, he said.
Both individuals and society as a whole are intolerant of the unknown, medical sociologists say.
Long before genetic screenings, there was a critical relationship between lab tests and medical treatment. Doctors often wont prescribe drugs or treatment without a positive test result. Insurance payments are rarely processed without diagnostic codes. The rise of genetic testing wont change, and may even amplify, that dynamic.
While some diagnoses may still carry social stigma think schizophrenia, for example they more often may confer legitimacy. Having a gene for alcoholism, for example, can make people view the problem as biological, as opposed to a character flaw. For patients, genetic tests promote a therapeutic optimism a hope that they can be treated and cured for an immediate problem or a future one, according to Michael Bury, professor emeritus at Royal Holloway, University of London, who studies society and illness.
A test alone can feel like a step forward. Undergoing a screening, said Natalie Armstrong, professor of healthcare improvement research at the University of Leicester, can make people feel that at least they are doing something proactive.
Interestingly, one study indicated that certain direct-to-consumer genetic tests dont affect users behavior or anxiety levels, bolstering the argument that people may use the information as data points, not a surefire prediction of their own fate.
Many bioethicists are unpersuaded. On an individual basis, it is tempting to discount the pitfalls of a little extra information, says Beth Peshkin, an oncology professor and genetic counselor at Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center in Washington, D.C. But on a population level the implications of inaccurate results can be costly and, sometimes, deadly.
One of the most cited examples of this harm is from a 2008 genetic test for ovarian cancer that misdiagnosed women, some of whom had their ovaries removed unnecessarily before the test was pulled from the market. Because test makers do not have to report when a test turns out to be wrong in fact many people may never know when a test result is a false positive or negative FDA officials have said it has been almost impossible to assess the overall harm from all unregulated tests.
Cost is another concern that may arise from the overuse of genetic tests that proliferate without meaningful oversight. Tests often beget more tests that cost an ever-escalating amount of money. Enough testing, will invariably pick up something abnormal in a patient, even though it may not harm them, some experts believe.
In some ways its easy for us to try and find something definitive and act on that even though it has nothing to do with what is wrong with the patient, said H. Gilbert Welch, a cancer research at Dartmouth College who has written extensively on the dangers of overtesting. Genetics is an amazing tool... but to what extent does that data predict something that you care about? Is it useful knowledge?
Get This Week in Opinion in your inbox:
Globe Opinion's must-reads, delivered to you every Sunday.
The American Clinical Laboratory Association, the key trade group for genetic test makers, and other advocates of lighter regulation argue that bad tests are rare, and that its more important for the free market to allow innovation. With more tests in place to identify disease, cures come next, they say.
So far, the public has shown little concern about the fallout of genetic testing. While a 2016 poll showed only 6 percent of American adults have undergone genetic testing, 56 percent of them said they would want to if it could predict cancer or a disease like Alzheimers. Most Americans, the poll found, believe genetic tests for predicting disease are mostly accurate and reliable.
Safety advocates best chance to tighten regulation may have already passed. The world of genetic testing becomes more free-wheeling and consumer-driven all the time. By one industry estimate, 10 new genetic testing products enter the market each day. Despite considerable skepticism from medical experts, new apps purport to use data from gene sequencing to develop personalized diet plans and fitness routines.
The FDAs now-shelved rules would have classified genetic and other tests according to how much harm they could cause if their result was wrong. For example, a new genetic test for colon cancer, which requires intrusive and costly treatment, likely would have been subject to full FDA review; the maker of a test that predicts mere baldness might only have had to register it with the agency and report any known problems with it. Under the Trump administration, the agency appears less likely to draw such distinctions or impose new restrictions at all.
People want answers soon, and their inclination is to believe what appears to be solid, unassailable medicine, said Robert Klitzman, a Columbia University bioethicist. Individuals will need to evaluate these tests carefully. The notion of being able to tell your fortune has great lure. But its a little bit of hubris. We still dont know so much.
Genetic testing, still in its infancy, promises a measure of clarity about the future of our bodies. But as genetic science rapidly evolves, that modern-day crystal ball raises vexing new questions and creates its own kind of uncertainty.
See more here:
Genetics for everyone - The Boston Globe
- Atossa Genetics: a focused pure play breast health testing company with huge potential to grow - January 3rd, 2013 [January 3rd, 2013]
- Genetics Introduction(with commentary)! - Video - January 19th, 2013 [January 19th, 2013]
- Genetics of Sickle Cell Disease - Video - January 15th, 2014 [January 15th, 2014]
- Atossa Genetics (ATOS) Multiple Bottom Pattern - Video - January 19th, 2014 [January 19th, 2014]
- How to plan an effective and efficient population genetics sampling strategy - Video - January 21st, 2014 [January 21st, 2014]
- Attack of the B-Team Advanced Genetics Mod Tutorial Ep.1 - Video - February 9th, 2014 [February 9th, 2014]
- Scientific Evidence for Creation CSE BIBLE FORUM Origins 1110 Creation Genetics - Video - February 9th, 2014 [February 9th, 2014]
- Genetics - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Is It Genetics Or Are You A Loser? - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Abbas Ravji - Keyword Genetics Review - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Minecraft: Attack of Mojo Jojo Episode 3 - Thermal Advanced Genetics! - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Q&A with Dr. Rudy Tanzi: Alzheimer's & Genetics - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Dr Shane McKee, Regional Medical Genetics Unit: Joining Information Together for Better Care - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Neil deGrasse Tyson on Genetics - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Timothytrespas-Genetics, chromaphores=nanoelectronics! Targeted Individual science. - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Advanced Genetics mod review have any mob's ability in minecraft - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- VaderOG Genetics Week 5 HD1080p - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Human Mutation Lora Bean, Madhuri Hegde, and Stuart Tinker - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Keyword Genetics - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Keyword Genetics | Use My Free System To Buy Keyword Genetics - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Keyword Genetics | Keyword Genetics Review - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Let's play Mace Griffin: Bounty Hunter - 14 - Genetics Lab - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Genetics: The Roots of Life - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Keyword Genetics Review - Should You Buy Keyword Genetics? - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Jurassic Genetics | Prototype Tech Demo ... Thing. - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- RR Let's Play - S02E33 - Advanced Genetics - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Genetics and law of probability when order specified and not specified - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Let's Play The Sims 3 - Perfect Genetics - Episode 37 - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Long overdue skunkhouse genetics update - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Let's Play The Sims 3 - Perfect Genetics - Episode 38 - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Hybrid Turkeys / Hendrix Genetics - Animal Aubsers - Office Invasion - Apr 11th, 2014 - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Attack of the Bteam Mod Tutorials - Advanced Genetics - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Keyword Genetics Review | Watch Video Keyword Genetics Demo - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Genetics and Inheritance - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Introduction to Population Genetics - Lynn Jorde (2014) - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Laser Genetics ND1 SubZero Tactical Laser Sight - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- How to solve genetics problems using factorials - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Keyword Genetics Review - How to use it? - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Theo's Strain Reviews Lemon Skunk from DNA Genetics - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Gerbil Colors And Genetics - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Simons Institute Open Lecture: Evolutionary Genetics in the Crush of Genomics - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- NewLink Genetics Presents Data at the AACR 2014 Annual Meeting - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- The Future of Genetics in Our Everyday Lives - SXSW Interactive 2014 (Full Session) - Video - April 18th, 2014 [April 18th, 2014]
- Laser Genetics ND5 Mini Subzero Long-distance Laser Illuminator - Video - April 18th, 2014 [April 18th, 2014]
- Shaman Genetics @ Spannabis 2014 (Espaol) - Video - April 18th, 2014 [April 18th, 2014]
- Attack of the Silverswords! Episode 11- Advanced Genetics - Video - April 18th, 2014 [April 18th, 2014]
- Mischa Janiec - Polska Genetics vs Kenzo Karagz - Turkesteron (Natural Bodybuilding) GNBF 2013 - Video - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- Class 30- 4/14/2014 - Video - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- Silvia Paracchini, PhD: Recent Advances in the Genetics of Dyslexia - Video - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- Holistic Alzheimer's Video Series: Genetics NOT the prime factor - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- The Role of Genetics in My Cancer - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- My Bad Genetics - Week 4 of Powerlifting - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- Minecraft: Feed The Beast Monster: Advanced Genetics! (Part 18) (Dutch Commentary) - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- Genetics Practice Problems - University of Cincinnati - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Introduction to genetics - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- How Genetics Help Understand Aging: Martin Denzel at TEDxJacobsUniversity - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- European Population Genetics: Haplogroup R-M343 Part 2 - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Attack Of The B Team Advanced Genetics Tutorial - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Skunk House Genetics - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Let's Play The Sims 3 - Perfect Genetics Challenge - Episode 15 - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Brandon Lilly - Genetics - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Can You Overcome Genetics? - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- My Parkinson's Story: Genetics - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- How Genetics Determine Your Baby's Gender - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Station genetics manager sad to leave, happy with progress - April 25th, 2014 [April 25th, 2014]
- Station genetics manager sad to leave - April 25th, 2014 [April 25th, 2014]
- Genetics | The Biology Corner - April 25th, 2014 [April 25th, 2014]
- Chaput Farms Improves Herd Genetics with CLARIFIDE - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- Cancer Genetics (NASDAQCM: CGIX) - RedChip Global Online CEO Conference - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- SkunkHouse Genetics update! - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- VaderOG Genetics Week 7 HD1080p - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- 23andMe Research: Understanding Genetics - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- Cancer and Genetics: Linda's Story - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- Laser Genetics ND3 Subzero Review - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- Let's Play The Sims 3 - Perfect Genetics Challenge - Episode 13 - Video - April 26th, 2014 [April 26th, 2014]
- R-Kiem Seeds Indoor Grow for Selecting Genetics - Video - April 27th, 2014 [April 27th, 2014]
- Let's Play The Sims 3 - Perfect Genetics Challenge - Episode 17 - Video - April 29th, 2014 [April 29th, 2014]
- Minecraft Tutorials - Advanced Genetics - The Basics - Video - April 29th, 2014 [April 29th, 2014]
- Dr. Judy Garber on Cancer Genetics - Video - April 29th, 2014 [April 29th, 2014]
- The Sims 3 Perfect Genetics Challenge: Rules - Video - April 30th, 2014 [April 30th, 2014]