High costs keep patients from using stem cells harvested from umbilical cords
Scientists are studying ways to treat HIV, cerebral palsy and other diseases using umbilical cord blood, although little of the collected blood will actually be used. Credit:Banc de Sang via flickr
Youd think doctors and patients would be clamoring for cells so versatile they could help reboot a body suffering from everything from leukemia to diabetes. But a new report shows that an important source of these stem cellsdiscarded umbilical cordsis rarely used because of high costs and the risk of failure.
Stem cells drawn from newborns umbilical cord blood are sometimes used to treat medical conditions, especially bone and blood cancers like multiple myeloma or lymphoma by replacing dysfunctional blood-producing cells in bone marrow. Generally the diseased cells are destroyed with chemotherapy and irradiation. Then new stem cells are transplanted into the patient to restore function. Cord blood stem cells are an alternative to bone marrow transplants and peripheral blood transplants, in which stem cells are gathered from the blood stream. Cord blood tends to integrate better with the body and it is easier to find a suitable donor than the alternatives.
Yet less than 3 percent of cord blood collected in the U.S. is ever used whereas the rest sits uselessly in blood banks, according to a recent report in Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News. Immunologist Enal Razvi is author of the report and managing director of Select Biosciences, a biotechnology consulting agency. Razvi found that public cord blood banks, which store donated frozen units for transplants as needed, have only a 1 to 3 percent turnover annually. Most of their inventory sits unused year after year. For example, at Community Blood Services in New Jersey, patients have only used 278 of its 13,000 cords since it opened in 1996, according to business development director Misty Marchioni. Usage is even lower at private cord blood banks, which charge clients thousands of dollars to store a cord in the event a family member one day needs it.
Unlike bone marrow, the main alternative stem cell source, cells transplanted from cord blood carry little risk of graft-versus-host disease, a deadly condition in which the body rejects a transplant. Scientists believe this is because a babys immune system is closer to a blank slate, so their stem cells can integrate with the patients body more easily. But cord blood transplants also take longer to start working, requiring longer hospital stays and upping the bill. Due to storage and testing costs, the cords themselves also get pricy. The cost of the cord is prohibitively high, Razvi explains. Each unit of cord blood costs between $35,000 and $40,000 and most adults require two units for a successful transplant. Insurance companies will generally pay a set amount for a stem cell transplant regardless of where the cells come from. The price tag on a cord blood transplant can run up to $300,000, which may not be fully covered.
Cord blood stem cell transplants also have a higher failure rate than other transplant methods. If the transplant fails, it leaves patients with a compromised immune system in addition to their original disease and medical bills. Because the preparation for transplant includes wiping out the patients original bone marrow, the entire body has to be repopulated with stem cells able to replace it. There are not many stem cells in each cord. Compared with bone marrow or peripheral blood there is a greater chance that there will not be enough stem cells that actually implant and begin producing blood and bone marrow. Its like spreading a small amount of seeds in a big garden, says Mitchell Horwitz, who teaches cell therapy at Duke University Medical Center. Sometimes it just doesnt take.
Martin Smithmyer, chief executive of the private bank Americord, claims that more clients will eventually use their cords, especially as more applications are found for cord blood stem cells. But some scientists disagree. Steven Joffe, a professor of medical ethics at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, says that many treatments cannot be done with a patients own stem cells because genetic diseases would already be present in the cord blood and that bone marrow might be a better option for relatives. The likelihood they are ever going to use that product is vanishingly small, he says.
Despite the low usage, advocates say cord blood programs have been crucial in improving transplant options for racial minorities, because it can be hard to find a bone marrow match for some groups. Cord blood does not need to match the patient as perfectly as bone marrow. This has transformed the treatment of minority patients, says Andromachi Scaradavou, medical director of the National Cord Blood Program, a public bank based in New York City. In the past we didnt have good donors to offer them. Community Blood Servicess Marchioni also maintains that cord blood is a good emergency option, because finding a compatible bone marrow or peripheral blood donor can take months or years. If you need a transplant quickly, she says, its easy to get cord blood off of a shelf.
Still, experts are working on more efficient ways of ensuring widespread availability of cord blood without having so much of it sit forever unused. Researchers are also continuing to look for ways to improve transplant success and to increase the number of stem cells obtained from each cord, potentially bringing down costs and making cord blood transplants feasible for more patients. If the cost could be lowered, Scaradavou says, it would help a lot of patients get the treatment they need.
Read more:
Vast Majority of Life-Saving Cord Blood Sits Unused
- Bone Marrow Transplant Stem Cell Transplant patient shares her experience at International Oncology - Video - March 29th, 2013 [March 29th, 2013]
- Ellen's journey through lymphoma and a stem cell transplant. - Video - April 23rd, 2013 [April 23rd, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant Hangout - Video - May 3rd, 2013 [May 3rd, 2013]
- Interview with Sarah Kelm of the Immunotherapy - May 13th, 2013 [May 13th, 2013]
- 'Off-the-shelf' virus-specific T-cells fight viral infections in stem cell transplant patients - May 15th, 2013 [May 15th, 2013]
- Dr. Patrick Stiff Named Chair of SWOG Bone Marrow and Stem Cell Transplantation Committee - May 18th, 2013 [May 18th, 2013]
- 2013 Blume-Schmidt Memorial Lecture - Stem cell transplant experts gather to honor pioneer - Video - May 27th, 2013 [May 27th, 2013]
- Study Shows Significantly Improved Survival Rates for Stem Cell Transplant Recipients - May 29th, 2013 [May 29th, 2013]
- Roy Jones - June 8th, 2013 [June 8th, 2013]
- Study sets guidelines for stem cell transplants in older patients with myelodysplastic syndromes - June 25th, 2013 [June 25th, 2013]
- Karmanos Cancer Center Blood and Marrow Stem Cell Transplant Program Gets Foundadtion Accreditation - June 25th, 2013 [June 25th, 2013]
- Bone marrow stem cell transplant reduces insulin usage in type 2 diabetes patients - June 29th, 2013 [June 29th, 2013]
- View From My Stem Cell Transplant Ward - Video - June 29th, 2013 [June 29th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant 2010 - Video - June 29th, 2013 [June 29th, 2013]
- Cml stem cell transplant Day (-6) - Video - July 1st, 2013 [July 1st, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant and Cellular Therapy Unit at CTCA in Philadelphia - Video - July 1st, 2013 [July 1st, 2013]
- CML Stem Cell Transplant Day (-5) - Video - July 4th, 2013 [July 4th, 2013]
- Ethan Zohn: What my stem cell transplant was like - Video - July 6th, 2013 [July 6th, 2013]
- Last of My Autologous Stem Cell Transplant - Video - July 7th, 2013 [July 7th, 2013]
- Cml stem cell transplant day (-1) - Video - July 7th, 2013 [July 7th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant Survivors Meet by Dr. Chirag Shah Part 3 - Video - July 11th, 2013 [July 11th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant Survivors Meet by Dr. Chirag Shah Part 2 - Video - July 11th, 2013 [July 11th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant Survivors Meet by Dr. Chirag Shah Part 1 - Video - July 11th, 2013 [July 11th, 2013]
- Argentine boy heads home after stem cell transplant at Duke - July 12th, 2013 [July 12th, 2013]
- Helping Julia in her fight for a stem cell transplant - Video - July 28th, 2013 [July 28th, 2013]
- Stem cell transplant will give Katy teen a new lease on life - August 1st, 2013 [August 1st, 2013]
- Scientists identify biomarker to predict immune response risk after stem cell transplants - August 7th, 2013 [August 7th, 2013]
- Andrew Madoff Battling Stage-Four Cancer, Receives Donor Infusion After Stem Cell Transplant - August 10th, 2013 [August 10th, 2013]
- CML Stem cell transplant day (-2) - Video - August 10th, 2013 [August 10th, 2013]
- CML Stem cell transplant day +34 - Video - August 10th, 2013 [August 10th, 2013]
- India stem cell transplant - Video - August 11th, 2013 [August 11th, 2013]
- Local Stem Cell Transplant Program Keeping More Patients Closer to Home (KDFA-TV, Amarillo) - Video - August 12th, 2013 [August 12th, 2013]
- How to Say or Pronounce Stem Cell Transplant - Video - August 21st, 2013 [August 21st, 2013]
- Girl, 10, shows no sign of sickle cell after stem cell transplant in St. Louis - September 1st, 2013 [September 1st, 2013]
- Three months after risky stem cell transplant, young patient shows no signs of sickle cell - September 1st, 2013 [September 1st, 2013]
- Neil Mitchell chats to Mauro about his Stem Cell Transplant - Alfred Hospital - Video - September 2nd, 2013 [September 2nd, 2013]
- Lorelei Decker shares good news following stem cell transplant - September 25th, 2013 [September 25th, 2013]
- Adult Stem Cell Transplant Saves Tony Underhill from Scleroderma - Video - September 30th, 2013 [September 30th, 2013]
- Peter's Stem cell transplant Journey - Video - October 7th, 2013 [October 7th, 2013]
- Presque Isle infant needs stem cell transplant to beat life-threatening illness - October 13th, 2013 [October 13th, 2013]
- Stem cell transplant repairs damaged gut in mouse model of inflammatory bowel disease - October 18th, 2013 [October 18th, 2013]
- Study evaluates early stem cell transplants for non-Hodgkin's lymphoma - October 31st, 2013 [October 31st, 2013]
- Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation - Wikipedia, the free ... - November 3rd, 2013 [November 3rd, 2013]
- Stem cell transplants : Cancer Research UK : CancerHelp UK - November 3rd, 2013 [November 3rd, 2013]
- Bone Marrow Transplant and Stem Cell Transplant Program, Siteman ... - November 3rd, 2013 [November 3rd, 2013]
- Stem cell transplants for non Hodgkin lymphoma : Cancer Research ... - November 3rd, 2013 [November 3rd, 2013]
- Katherine's stem cell transplant - Video - November 3rd, 2013 [November 3rd, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant - Dana-Farber Cancer Institute - November 11th, 2013 [November 11th, 2013]
- Peripheral Blood Stem Cell Transplant Donor, Procedure, Benefits ... - November 11th, 2013 [November 11th, 2013]
- A Journey Through A Stem Cell Transplant - Diane M. Sullivan - Video - November 11th, 2013 [November 11th, 2013]
- Bone Marrow - Dr B S Rajput Stem Cell Transplant Surgeon - Video - November 16th, 2013 [November 16th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplant Blog - November 18th, 2013 [November 18th, 2013]
- LHC Better Living: Stem Cell Transplant - Video - November 18th, 2013 [November 18th, 2013]
- India stem cell transplant by Dr B S Rajput stem cell transplant Surgeon - Video - November 21st, 2013 [November 21st, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplants For Incurable and Untreatable Diseases ... - November 23rd, 2013 [November 23rd, 2013]
- Type of Treatment - Stem Cell Transplantation | MD Anderson ... - November 23rd, 2013 [November 23rd, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplantations: Cancer Treatment | MD Anderson ... - November 24th, 2013 [November 24th, 2013]
- Datri 1st successful unrelated Blood Stem Cell Transplant - Video - November 24th, 2013 [November 24th, 2013]
- India stem cell transplant bone marrow by Dr. B. S. Rajput stem cell transplant surgeon - Video - November 26th, 2013 [November 26th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplants - Nemours: Kids Health - November 27th, 2013 [November 27th, 2013]
- Stem Cell Transplantation for Cancer Treatment | CTCA - November 29th, 2013 [November 29th, 2013]
- Bone Marrow/Stem Cell Transplant - Video - November 29th, 2013 [November 29th, 2013]
- Treatment Options - Stem Cell Transplantation - December 3rd, 2013 [December 3rd, 2013]
- Stem cell transplant: All - MayoClinic.com - December 4th, 2013 [December 4th, 2013]
- The Phases Of Stem Cell Transplant Treatment - Video - December 5th, 2013 [December 5th, 2013]
- Recurrent follicular lymphoma: Novel approaches vs stem cell transplant - Video - December 5th, 2013 [December 5th, 2013]
- Breakthrough in Treating Leukemia, Lymphoma Patients with Umbilical Cord Blood Stem Cells - December 12th, 2013 [December 12th, 2013]
- Advances in stem cell transplantation strategies show promise to improve availability, success - December 12th, 2013 [December 12th, 2013]
- Wilson undergoes transplant on Thursday - December 12th, 2013 [December 12th, 2013]
- Breakthrough in treating leukemia, lymphoma with umbilical cord blood stem cells - December 12th, 2013 [December 12th, 2013]
- HIV Returns in Two Men Thought Cured After Stem Cell Transplant - December 12th, 2013 [December 12th, 2013]
- Wilson resting following stem cell transplant - December 13th, 2013 [December 13th, 2013]
- Boyd: 'I am cancer-free' - December 15th, 2013 [December 15th, 2013]
- Bone Marrow Harvest for Stem Cell Transplant - Video - December 16th, 2013 [December 16th, 2013]
- Bone Marrow Stem Cell Transplant - Video - December 16th, 2013 [December 16th, 2013]
- Amyloidosis - Ongoing Research and Collaboration - Video - December 16th, 2013 [December 16th, 2013]
- Ruxolitinib before Stem Cell Transplant - Video - December 16th, 2013 [December 16th, 2013]
- The Multi Disciplinary Team Involved In A Stem Cell Transplant - Video - December 16th, 2013 [December 16th, 2013]
- Liver cells benefit from mesenchymal stem cell co-culture prior to transplantation - December 19th, 2013 [December 19th, 2013]
- Why Amyloidosis: Two Doctors Discuss Their Paths To The Disease - Video - December 19th, 2013 [December 19th, 2013]