LGBT people have gained more legal recognition in recent years, but LGBT rights remain a central issue in Indiana politics. Stephanie Wang/IndyStar
Jackie and Lisa Phillips-Stackman hold their daughter, Lola, at their Indianapolis home, Friday, Dec. 4, 2015. The couple are filing a lawsuit against the state to try to get Indiana to recognize both same-sex parents on their children's birth certificates.(Photo: Michelle Pemberton/The Star)
In oral arguments Monday, a panel of three judges for the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals examined whetherIndiana discriminates by not recognizing two married women both as parents on their children's birth certificates without having to adopt.
Judge Diane S. Sykesdrew distinctions betweenbiological parentage and parental rights, and which of the two should be represented on birth certificates.
"You can't overcome biology," Sykes said. "If the state defines parenthood by virtue of biology, no argument under the Equal Protection Clause or the substantive due process clause can overcome that."
"Your Honor, with all due respect, we maintain that parenthood is no longer defined by biology," said Karen Celestino-Horseman, the attorney for eight same-sex couples who brought the lawsuit against the state for only allowing only a mother and a father to be named on birth certificates.
"That's a policy argument to take to the legislature," Sykes responded.
The state of Indiana is appealing a ruling by a district judgewho sidedwith the same-sex couplesand ordered the state to recognize both women as parents on birth certificates of children who are conceived through a sperm donor.
"In our view, that order creates an inequality that did not exist before and undermines the rights of biological fathers and their children," said Indiana Solicitor General Thomas Fisher.
Read the back story: Same-sex couples sue state over birth certificates
More on politics: Tully: A few thoughts about the Mike Pence protests
Trump's education plan: DeVos: School choice should expand, but not from Washington D.C.
The couples' case argued that parental recognition should be a benefit conferred by the U.S. Supreme Court's marriage equality ruling in 2015, known as Obergefell v. Hodges.
Prior to the lawsuit, the spouse who was not the birth mother would have to adopt the child, even if her egg was used for the pregnancy. That was the case for Indianapolis couple Jackie and Lisa Phillips-Stackman, who are part of the lawsuit.
Not recognizing the non-birthmother, the lawsuit said, could make it more difficult for families to be covered by insurance policies, or for the parent to enroll her child in school.
The adoption process, which can be costly, amends the birth certificate to recognize adoptive parents. The original record, Fisher said, is still retained.
But the lawsuit contended that spouses should be recognized as a parent when the child is born because of her wedded status similar to how married opposite-sex couples are often treated, where the husband can be presumed to be the father.
"The statute creates a paternity presumption that just is impossible in a same-sex marriage situation," Sykes said, referring to the state statute on birth certificates that the couples are challenging.
"Your Honor," Celestino-Horseman said, "that's if one still presumes that parenthood is still defined"
Sykes interrupted: "It's not a parenthood statute. It's a paternity statute. Paternity presumption is impossible in a same-sex marriage situation. So we just don't have any kind of discrimination going on here at all."
Later, Sykes said that what the couples may be seeking is a redefinition of parenthood.
"Your Honor," Celestino-Horseman said, "parenthood"
Sykes interrupted again: " is biological or adopted. You want this third category."
As Celestino-Horseman cited relevant cases, Sykes delineated between marriage cases and parenthood cases.
In pregnancies using a sperm donor, opposite-sex couples can say the husband is the father of the child but that same presumption of parenthood doesn't extend to a wife in a same-sex couple who isn't the birth mother, the lawsuit argued.
The state of Indiana countered that opposite-sex couples aren't supposed to do that. The mother is supposed to state when the husband is not the father. But that's not what often happens in real life.
"That led me to think that your argument is that a state law becomes unconstitutional because people subject to the state law don't follow it," Judge Frank H. Easterbrook said, "which would be a very difficult position to take."
The debate, he said, would then be about how state law is supposed to operate not whether it discriminates.
Easterbrook asked how the couples' case would apply to two married men who have a child through artificial insemination.
Celestino-Horseman indicated the situation was more complicated because it would involve surrogacy.
"I don't want to be the one to tell you this, but Obergefell says there can't be any sex discrimination, and now you're saying there must be sex discrimination," Easterbrook said. "In a female-female marriage, the right answer is mother No. 1 and mother No. 2. In a male-male marriage, the right answer is surrogate mother, sperm donor, followed by adoption. In your view, doesn't there have to be identical treatment of the male-male marriage and the female-female marriage?"
News alerts delivered to your phone:Download IndyStar app for breaking news, sports.
Celestino-Horseman responded that wasn't part of the case.
"We can't ignorethe logical implications of your arguments. And you seem to want to," Easterbrook replied.
He added that the case aimed to require "a mis-recording of who the father is."
"Your view seems to be that it is unconstitutional for Indiana to correctly record the parent," he said.
The Seventh Circuit is taking the case under advisement and may rule at a later date.
Call IndyStar reporter Stephanie Wang at (317) 444-6184. Follow her on Twitter: @stephaniewang.
Read or Share this story: http://indy.st/2rLLPSp
See more here:
Judge to Indiana same-sex couples: 'You can't overcome biology' - The Courier-Journal
- Howard H. Seliger, Hopkins biology professor - January 1st, 2013 [January 1st, 2013]
- General Biology-Concepts and Investigations - Video - January 31st, 2013 [January 31st, 2013]
- Biology Reproduction part 13 (Sexual reproduction: Flower Structure) CBSE class 10 X - Video - January 9th, 2014 [January 9th, 2014]
- How far can a Buddhist approach to biology take us? - January 14th, 2014 [January 14th, 2014]
- Biology revision song on protein synthesis by Andrew Perkins - Video - January 30th, 2014 [January 30th, 2014]
- Scientific Evidence for Creation CSE BIBLE FORUM Origins 1212 Dr Seuss Biology - Video - February 9th, 2014 [February 9th, 2014]
- Synthetic biology lab backed by 2 million award - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Vanguard High teacher wins 2014 Shell Science Lab Challenge - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Biohacking and the problem of bioterrorism - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Synthetic genetic clock keeps accurate time across a range of temperatures - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Math modeling integral to synthetic biology research - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Vacancies in biology dept. impact course options - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Dr. Joshua Reece Earns Best Presentation Award At Conference - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Life Science Reference - Biology Online - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- 9th Grade Biology: A Hectic Introduction to Mammals - Video - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Theism vs Evolution, Biology, and History - Video - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- AP Biology Ch.49 Circulatory System Livestream - Video - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- AP Biology Review Cards - Video - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- AP Biology - Chapter 49 Circulatory System Part 1 - Video - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- MSc Biology and PhD Boreal Ecology - Video - April 9th, 2014 [April 9th, 2014]
- Whale tales: Students set sail for biology class research - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Barnard biology professor honored with Emily Gregory award for teaching - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- biology: Definition from Answers.com - Answers - The Most ... - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Biology - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Bridging the Brain Disease Knowledge Gap through Computational Modeling and Systems Biology: An O... - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Sharpening microscope images: New technique takes cues from astronomy, ophthalmology - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- COLLEGE NEWS: April 13 - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Eureka Once, Eureka Twice - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Biology - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- The Art of Nutrients - Biology Song - 'Counting Stars' Remake - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Biology - The Nervous System - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- OCR AS BIOLOGY: - Cell Structures - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Evolutionary Biology Research / F. Robin O'Keefe and Julie Meachen / Page Museum - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- What Is a Thyroid In Biology? : Let's Get Medical - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Red Ice Radio - Sofia Smallstorm - Hour 1 - Chemtrails to Pseudo-Life & Synthetic Biology - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- STARNES: Did professor advocate censorship of conservative student newspaper? - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- German Research Foundation approves new priority program in the life sciences - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Announcing BioCoder issue 3 - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Poetry by Linda Bierds, Buddhism and biology - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Digestion - Biology Music Video - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- AS Level Biology- Edexcel/SNAB- Unit 1 Revision Notes - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- The Anatomy Of The Heart - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- #OilerNation Biology Program Q & A Hangout - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Northwestern University researchers on synthetic biology - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Gregor Mendel Institute of Molecular Plant Biology (Vienna) - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Biology 1B - 2014-04-14 - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- AP Biology Review 3/7: Cell Energy - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- MCB 410: Developmental Biology - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Dyslexic Advantage - UCSF Symposium - Dr Fumiko Hoeft - Biology of Stealth Dyslexia - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Life cycle of Silkworm- Insect Molecular Biology Lab, Dr.M.Krishnan, Bharathithasan University. - Video - April 16th, 2014 [April 16th, 2014]
- Tracking flu levels with Wikipedia - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Biology major Katharine Leigh '15 wins Udall scholarship - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- First in the nation: UW-Madison establishes post-doc in feminist biology - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Biology Project: Predation - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Report Focussing On Biology Underlining - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- edX | MITx: Quantitative Biology Workshop: 7QBWx About Video - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Cell Mediated Response (Erdmann's 2B-3 AP Biology) - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Biology Plantae part 13 (Mosses: structure, life cycle, mosses vs leafy liverwots) CBSE class 11 XI - Video - April 17th, 2014 [April 17th, 2014]
- Biology - Photosynthesis - Video - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- The Genie in Your Genes: Epigenetics and Biology of Intention - Video - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- Introduction to Synthetic Biology Andrew Hessel - Video - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- Teacher of Biology - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- Biology - Osmosis - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- UW to host first feminist biology post-doc program in nation - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- The Biology Project: Cell Biology - University of Arizona - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- The Biology Corner - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Rader's BIOLOGY 4 KIDS.COM - Biology basics for everyone! - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Stanford CF Education Day 2014 Understanding the Biology - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- 9th Grade Biology: Hectic Introduction to the Human Organ Systems pt.1 - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Honors Biology and Biology Mrs. Ellis - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Biology professor researches parasites - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- TRANSCRIPTION-Biology - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- 2014 Interdisciplinary Innovation Forum: "Mathematical Biology" - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- This Week in Genome Biology - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Biology - Calvin Cycle - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Systems biology course 2014 Uri Alon - lecture 3: FFL and more - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Systems biology course 2014 Uri Alon - lecture 2: Auto regulation - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Systems biology course 2014 Uri Alon - lecture 1: Basic concepts - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- 9th Grade Biology: Hectic Introduction to the Human Organ Systems pt.2 - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Have Atheists Hijacked Biology? - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]