Of all the ways the body can go wrong, A.L.S. is one of the most frightening. It begins subtly a twitching muscle, a cough when you swallow or a clumsy hand. But then it progresses. Motor neurons degenerate and die. You lose the ability to talk, to eat and ultimately to breathe. There is no cure. Treatment will slow progression somewhat, but not enough.
A diagnosis of A.L.S., or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, begins a race against the clock. What do you do to make yourself heard before you are rendered voiceless? How do you find a trial or a treatment to extend time long enough to be there for the next scientific advance?
I rarely have time to probe the answers to these questions when I take care of people with A.L.S. in the intensive care unit or long-term hospital ward. But the faces stay with me. I remember a woman who just wanted to go to the beach once more, to eat a lobster roll before she could no longer swallow. I remember a young man with an elaborate sound system in his hospital room whose wife had left him; there was no one to take care of him at home, and so he would live out his days in a nursing facility.
In contrast to the experience of those with cancer, for whom there is often the promise of a new drug around the bend, there are relatively few therapies for A.L.S. Perhaps that is why I became so interested recently in the vigorous debate over the possible approval by the Food and Drug Administration of a new treatment for A.L.S.: a stem cell therapy called NurOwn developed by BrainStorm Cell Therapeutics. Some patients who had early access to the drug described improvement like being able to pick up a remote control for the first time in months or being able to walk through the grass.
But the data did not bear out these experiences. Ultimately, the F.D.A. advisory committee that evaluated NurOwn recommended against approving the therapy, a decision that devastated many A.L.S. patients and their family members.
This is the latest in a sequence of controversial drug approval decisions from Alzheimers to muscular dystrophy that see educated and impassioned patient advocates pleading their case before regulatory authorities. These debates extend beyond the quality of scientific evidence. The decision of whether to approve a drug for a lethal disease gets to complex, deeply human questions. How far do you go when the alternative is certain death? What level of proof is good enough, and who gets to decide? And when someone is facing a terminal illness, what is the cost and benefit of hope, even hope for an outcome that might never be realized?
A few years ago, I began to follow a man named Brian Wallach on social media. It was some time after his A.L.S. diagnosis in 2017, back when his voice was still audible and he could ride his Peloton stationary bicycle. He was around my age, in his late 30s at the time, with a wife and two young daughters. He described his disease, somewhat hopefully, as currently fatal.
After all, when he was diagnosed on the day his newborn daughter came home from the hospital a new drug for A.L.S. had recently been approved. Surely there were more in the pipeline. The first neurologist he saw had told him that he would be dead in six months, and that he should go home and eat whatever he wanted and be with his family. But the specialists he went on to see pointed him in the direction of clinical trials.
Mr. Wallach knew that A.L.S. is a terminal illness. That knowledge was with him every moment of every day. But if there was a hope for a different outcome, he wanted to grab hold of it. So Mr. Wallach and his wife, Sandra Abrevaya, researched the existing data for drugs that had been proven safe and had some evidence of benefit. They knew that no one drug would offer a magic bullet. But perhaps in combination, the available treatments could help slow the progression of Mr. Wallachs A.L.S. enough so that he would still be alive when the next drug became available. There was no time to wait.
They drew on their skills and connections Mr. Wallach is a lawyer while Ms. Abrevaya has headed nonprofit organizations, and both worked in the Obama White House to build what has been described as the most successful patient advocacy campaign in decades. They catalyzed new research, helped pass a bill to allocate millions in federal money to A.L.S. studies and improved access to promising investigational drugs for patients who are not eligible for clinical trials. (The nonprofit that Mr. Wallach and Ms. Abrevaya founded, I AM ALS, provided a $100,000 grant to BrainStorm for its research into NurOwn.) Mr. Wallach would be among the first generation to survive A.L.S., he wrote on the social media platform X.
I want to believe this. Though he is nearly completely paralyzed and his voice is so weak that his wife serves as his translator, he is alive six years after his diagnosis, still breathing on his own. That itself is remarkable.
And yet as doctors particularly those of us working in places like the I.C.U. we are trained to tread cautiously when it comes to hope. We applaud families for being realistic, which generally means that they do not ask for outcomes we consider to be impossible. We guard carefully against what we think of as false hope or hope for an outcome that we believe cannot come to pass. If hope even false hope is a kind of medicine, it is not one that we are comfortable with.
That said, maybe hope despite long odds is not always the worst thing, especially when the alternative is no hope at all. For many A.L.S. patients, that is what NurOwn represented. According to BrainStorm, the treatment involves stem cells harvested from patients bone marrow and engineered in a lab to prevent nerve damage and cell death associated with A.L.S. Those cells are then given back to the patients through injections into the spine. The science was exciting, the early data promising.
But the data from the companys largest trial, enrolling nearly 200 patients, were negative the treatment was no better than placebo in the full patient population. Further analyses suggested those with a milder form of A.L.S. may benefit, but the subgroup population was small and these improvements fell short of consistently meeting the bar of statistical significance.
Patients offered impassioned testimony, describing how NurOwn had given them back a bit of their autonomy and stilled the relentless pace of this disease. The drug would not work for everyone. But for patients facing certain death, the idea that it might help some of them was enough, even if that had not been borne out in a rigorous scientific study.
Unconvinced, and despite the F.D.A.s promise to be more flexible when it comes to approving drugs for fatal diseases, the advisory committee nearly unanimously voted against recommending NurOwn for approval. I cant know if that was the right decision. Maybe a larger trial would have proven NurOwn to be beneficial and maybe not. BrainStorm is now working with the F.D.A. to design another trial. But for patients whose disease is rapidly progressing, now, those results might come too late.
There is a narrative that desperate patients would try anything, and the role of the F.D.A. and the health care system more broadly is to protect those patients against themselves. That is flawed. Mr. Wallach and Ms. Abrevaya are indeed desperate. Their lives have been ravaged by this disease. But their judgment is still intact. Their decisions are not influenced by the nihilism that comes from despair. They simply want the ability to decide for themselves whether to take drugs that might be helpful.
Of course, no one wants the F.D.A. to approve drugs that are useless or, worse still, dangerous. And the F.D.A. has made decisions in recent years that demonstrate a willingness to make available drugs for lethal diseases based on imperfect data, most controversially with the Alzheimers drug Aduhelm, but also with other A.L.S. treatments. But where does this flexibility end? Where do we draw that line?
One worry is that increasing flexibility will mean the F.D.A. is influenced by the loudest voices to put drugs on the market that are expensive and possibly ineffective. But isnt it also dangerous, maybe more so, to be wrong in the other direction to withhold a drug that might actually be beneficial, when the alternative is certain death? The treatments may not cure us, but they have a chance to help us, Mr. Wallach said. And that chance is everything, when you know what is behind door number two.
I thought of this conversation and of the NurOwn debate recently, as I walked through the long-term acute care hospital. I was taking care of a man in his 40s with a debilitating disease that had caused his muscles to shrink and atrophy, leaving him on the ventilator. From the bed, he mouthed to me that he was hoping to try to breathe on his own for at least part of the day. Looking at him, I was fairly sure that would be impossible.
I felt myself start to explain to him how unlikely that outcome was. Surely I should prepare him and guard him against false hope. But then I paused. The time might come for that. But for the moment, we would try.
Daniela Lamas is a contributing Opinion writer and a pulmonary and critical-care physician at Brigham and Womens Hospital in Boston.
The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. Wed like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And heres our email: letters@nytimes.com.
Follow the New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X and Threads.
Go here to see the original:
Opinion | A Rejected A.L.S. Drug Made Me Rethink the Role of Hope in Medicine - The New York Times
- Jake Diekman throws BP session for Rangers | MLB.com - MLB.com - August 6th, 2017 [August 6th, 2017]
- Cerebral palsy: Symptoms, diagnosis, treatment - December 5th, 2017 [December 5th, 2017]
- Hypothalamus - the body's thermostat | ASU - Ask A Biologist - December 6th, 2017 [December 6th, 2017]
- When Stroke Affects the Thalamus - Stroke Connection ... - December 28th, 2017 [December 28th, 2017]
- The Endocrine System: Hypothalamus and Pituitary - December 28th, 2017 [December 28th, 2017]
- Hypothalamus - Anatomy, Blood supply and Function | Kenhub - December 28th, 2017 [December 28th, 2017]
- Ulcerative Colitis - Cedars-Sinai - January 6th, 2018 [January 6th, 2018]
- Ulcerative colitis - Treatment - NHS.UK - January 7th, 2018 [January 7th, 2018]
- Business Directory | Uptown Waterloo Business Improvement Area - January 8th, 2018 [January 8th, 2018]
- Will States Continue To Fund Stem Cell Research? : Shots ... - January 28th, 2018 [January 28th, 2018]
- Spinal Cord Injuries - emedicine.medscape.com - February 15th, 2018 [February 15th, 2018]
- Spinal Cord Injuries - spine.org - February 15th, 2018 [February 15th, 2018]
- Journal of Clinical & Experimental Cardiology - Open Access Journals - April 10th, 2018 [April 10th, 2018]
- Cardiology Treatment - Fortis Healthcare - April 10th, 2018 [April 10th, 2018]
- Biology Junction - April 12th, 2018 [April 12th, 2018]
- Managing Right Ventricular Failure in PAH: An Algorithmic ... - April 14th, 2018 [April 14th, 2018]
- Ticagrelor vs Clopidogrel After Fibrinolytic Therapy in ... - April 22nd, 2018 [April 22nd, 2018]
- Cardiovascular Pharmacotherapeutics: William H. Frishman ... - May 13th, 2018 [May 13th, 2018]
- 13 Super Foods Good for Eczema - Top Eczema Treatments - May 15th, 2018 [May 15th, 2018]
- Diagnosis & Treatment of Parkinson's - ParkinsonsDisease.net - May 30th, 2018 [May 30th, 2018]
- Arizona Heart Rhythm Center - June 10th, 2018 [June 10th, 2018]
- Ayurvedic Medicines for Ulcerative Colitis | Natural ... - June 21st, 2018 [June 21st, 2018]
- Weinstein Cardiovascular Development and Regeneration Meeting - June 30th, 2018 [June 30th, 2018]
- Ulcerative Colitis Information Centre - July 31st, 2018 [July 31st, 2018]
- Sudden Death in Dogs - Pet Health Network | Pet Health ... - August 7th, 2018 [August 7th, 2018]
- Coronary Heart Disease - Ischaemic heart disease - British ... - August 21st, 2018 [August 21st, 2018]
- Cardiac Rehabilitation: Overview, History and Definition ... - August 25th, 2018 [August 25th, 2018]
- Difference between Cardiac Arrest and Respiratory Arrest ... - August 25th, 2018 [August 25th, 2018]
- ECM for Pericardial Closure - Aziyo - August 25th, 2018 [August 25th, 2018]
- Adult Mental Health | Georgia Department of Behavioral Health ... - September 6th, 2018 [September 6th, 2018]
- Mental Health | ECLKC - September 6th, 2018 [September 6th, 2018]
- Mental Health - The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints - September 6th, 2018 [September 6th, 2018]
- Center for Vascular Biology - Home | UConn Health - September 22nd, 2018 [September 22nd, 2018]
- # Diabetes Stem Cell Research Diabetes Care Measures - September 30th, 2018 [September 30th, 2018]
- Cardiac Rhythm Disturbances | The Patient Guide to Heart ... - November 2nd, 2018 [November 2nd, 2018]
- Arrhythmia | Cleveland Clinic - November 2nd, 2018 [November 2nd, 2018]
- Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy for Wound Healing | Johns ... - November 13th, 2018 [November 13th, 2018]
- NIMH Home - November 24th, 2018 [November 24th, 2018]
- What is an interventional cardiologist? | Heart Surgeries ... - November 26th, 2018 [November 26th, 2018]
- Molecular Cardiology Research Institute Boston | Tufts ... - November 29th, 2018 [November 29th, 2018]
- Lower vascular plant | botany | Britannica.com - December 7th, 2018 [December 7th, 2018]
- Welcome to the ABG Tutorial Welcome to Hansen - December 12th, 2018 [December 12th, 2018]
- Cardiac catheterization - Wikipedia - December 12th, 2018 [December 12th, 2018]
- Stem Cell Research & Therapy | Home page - December 22nd, 2018 [December 22nd, 2018]
- Journal of Stem Cell Research and Therapy- Open Access ... - December 22nd, 2018 [December 22nd, 2018]
- Stem-cell therapy - Wikipedia - December 22nd, 2018 [December 22nd, 2018]
- Cardiology and Interventional Cardiology - December 23rd, 2018 [December 23rd, 2018]
- Rhode Island Interventional Cardiology | Cardiovascular ... - December 23rd, 2018 [December 23rd, 2018]
- Interventional Cardiology Certification Policies | ABIM.org - December 23rd, 2018 [December 23rd, 2018]
- Interventional Cardiology - Boston Scientific - December 23rd, 2018 [December 23rd, 2018]
- 9 Benefits of Human Growth Hormone (Along with Side ... - December 27th, 2018 [December 27th, 2018]
- Growth hormone deficiency - Wikipedia - December 27th, 2018 [December 27th, 2018]
- Dr. Lorrie Kirshenbaum, Cardiac Gene Biology | St ... - January 28th, 2019 [January 28th, 2019]
- Cardiomyopathy - CardioSmart - February 8th, 2019 [February 8th, 2019]
- Centenary Institute | Medical Research, Life Saving Research - February 24th, 2019 [February 24th, 2019]
- Cardiovascular Medicine | Department of Medicine - March 29th, 2019 [March 29th, 2019]
- Rapid Test Market 2019 with Recent Trends, Revenue, Demand and Top Manufactures- Bureau Veritas, SGS SA, Intertek Group plc, Eurofins Scientific -... - October 11th, 2019 [October 11th, 2019]
- Medical Imaging Equipment Market Research Report 2019: Global Industry Analysis, Business Development, Size, Share, Trends, Future Growth, Forecast To... - October 11th, 2019 [October 11th, 2019]
- Analysis on the Global DNA Read, Write & Edit Market, 2017-2019 and Forecast to 2024 - Yahoo Finance - October 11th, 2019 [October 11th, 2019]
- Cardiac Surgery Instruments Market is Expected to Tread a Steady Growth Trajectory by Clocking a CAGR of 5.9% from 2017 to 2022 - Health News Office - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- PEDIATRIC MEDICAL DEVICES MARKET IS PROJECTED TO EXPAND AT A CAGR OF 8.0% FROM 2018 TO 2026 - Health News Office - November 1st, 2019 [November 1st, 2019]
- myTAIHEART Test Provides Evidence for Injury from Biopsy of Heart Transplant Recipients Cardiology2.0 - Cardiology2.0 - November 1st, 2019 [November 1st, 2019]
- Mental health and your heart - British Heart Foundation - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- BUZZ-U.S. STOCKS ON THE MOVE-Cango, Gulfport Energy, Abiomed, Standard Diversified, Wanda Sports, Eidos - Nasdaq - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- Cost Analysis of COPD Exacerbations and Cardiovascular Events in SUMMIT - AJMC.com Managed Markets Network - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- Hundreds walk to defeat ALS in Ancient City - St. Augustine Record - November 22nd, 2019 [November 22nd, 2019]
- Living with Lung Cancer: The Silver Linings - Curetoday.com - November 22nd, 2019 [November 22nd, 2019]
- Building the human spinal cord atlas - SynBioBeta - November 22nd, 2019 [November 22nd, 2019]
- The Week That Wasn't: Keto and the Flu, Human Cyborg, Duvet Disease - Medscape - November 22nd, 2019 [November 22nd, 2019]
- ALS advance offers hope for those diagnosed with deadly disease - WRAL.com - November 22nd, 2019 [November 22nd, 2019]
- ALS Stem Cell Therapy Developer Seeks Amendment to its AstroRx Trial - ALS News Today - November 22nd, 2019 [November 22nd, 2019]
- Former Boston Globe writer, current NHL executive Snow diagnosed with ALS | College Hockey - USCHO - December 23rd, 2019 [December 23rd, 2019]
- AB Science announces the publication of new results in the peer-reviewed journal Glia that further support masitinib's potential mode of action in ALS... - December 23rd, 2019 [December 23rd, 2019]
- Christmas in the City thrills homeless families, takes on poignancy with founders ALS diagnosis - The Boston Globe - December 23rd, 2019 [December 23rd, 2019]
- Amylyx Pharmaceuticals Announces AMX0035 Demonstrated Statistically Significant Treatment Benefit for People with ALS in the CENTAUR Trial - Business... - December 23rd, 2019 [December 23rd, 2019]
- RADICAVA (edaravone) - December 23rd, 2019 [December 23rd, 2019]
- List of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Medications (5 Compared ... - December 23rd, 2019 [December 23rd, 2019]
- Neuropore Completes Phase 1 Clinical Trial in Healthy Volunteers with NPT520-34, a Therapeutic Candidate Aimed at Treating Parkinson's Disease and... - January 14th, 2020 [January 14th, 2020]
- Comprehensive Analysis on Prostacyclin Market based on types and application - Technology Magazine - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]
- N.J. karate legend who inspired thousands loses battle with ALS - NJ.com - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]