The US Supreme Courts Dobbs decision striking down the constitutional right to abortion (which has sparked a renewed debate over when human life begins) all but guarantees that the issue of setting research limits on fetal tissue testing will be contested in the US courts and in the court of public opinion.
Many of those with ethical doubts look at the issue through an idiosyncratic lens. The discord in their analytical approaches is troubling and provides an unreliable basis to address the issue. Those focusing on the moral issues raised by the Supreme Court and question at what point is the embryo a person are likely to claim that the 14-day rule should be abolished altogether, and no embryo research should be permitted.
According to one interpretation, by professor Sonia Suter of George Washington University, Dobbs vests in the state the right to make laws affecting
the potential life and for the unborn human being [which] can be expressed through laws showing respect for and preservation of life at all stages of development (emphasis added). It makes no distinction between implanted embryos and embryos created in vitro (i.e., in the laboratory, lit. in the glass, whether petri dish or test tube), whether fresh or frozen.
Extending this reasoning to the debate over the 14-day rule is inevitable. Numerous American and Canadian ethicists have expressed concerns about setting a hard 28-day limit as there is little scientific, and in some cases limited ethical reasoning behind this number. As prominent ethicist Henry (Hank) Greely, Director of the Stanford Center for Law and the Biosciences, has written, Even though I do not personally give strong moral status to embryos, the idea of doing research on 18-day-old[sic] human embryos is disturbing.
While Warnock, Jasanoff, Greely and other ethicists believe the public needs to sound in, they provide no basis upon which an untutored populace should base their decisions. The crux of the question, then, is who should decide? Should this be a scientific question to be determined (or at least guided) by science bodies? Or a purely moral and ethical issue to be determined by society-at-large?
In 2017,Baroness Warnock explainedwhy the committee she oversaw in 1984 set the 14-day limit.
We did pick on a number of days after which we understood that the embryo began to develop more swiftly toward becoming a curled-up fetus with a spinal cord and a central nervous system, she wrote.
The groundbreaking report resolved a dichotomy in her committee; she recommended what she claimed was a middle ground between science and ethics in an attempt to reconcile proponents and opponents of embryo research even though she didnt give much credence to a science-based inquiry as an objective tool. As she wrote in her 204 book The Making of British Bioethics:
First, scientific evidence offered no resolution, as both sides used data on embryological development to justify their particular standpoint. The interpretation of scientific facts here was not a neutral activity, since the question of which facts mattered was clearly shaped by an individuals moral preferences.
She highlighted the relevant biological factors including the initial development of the nervous system and the beginning of gastrulation:
In biological terms, the 15thday of embryo development is the point when the primitive streak forms: that is, the beginning of gastrulation when three layers of germ cells differentiate. The 14thday is therefore notable, because the embryo is then individuated and can no longer become a twin.
But Warnock and her group gave the biological basis for the 14-day solution a moral gloss: the cut-off was decided upon to mark the ability of the cellular entity to supposedly feel pain, inferred from the beginnings of the nervous system development, but was couched as sentience, even though this would be a far cry from sentience as is generally conceived. And the biological demarcation of a definite, single human individual or individualization was considered the beginnings of the emergence of the individuals identity, a psychological or social concept.
Perhaps, philosopher-Warnock gave the science short shrift. Lets explore further.
Strictly speaking a zygote (the product of the fertilization of the gametes, egg and sperm,) isnt even called an embryo, at least in the scientific universe, until two or three weeks after the gametes unite. Immediately after fertilization, the cells begin dividing. After four days, at the 16 to 30 cell stage of development, the undifferentiated clump of cells looks like a mulberry and is called a morula (Latin for mulberry).
On the fifth day of development, the morula now has a structure, becoming the blastocyst (the point IVF researchers and embryologists test the motley cellular group for genetic defects to assure the best chance of successful impregnation). The blastocyst structure has an inner cell mass, the embryonic stem cells, from which the embryo develops.
Two weeks or so after fertilization the first nervous system cells are formed, the entity is implanted in the uterus, and the entity is now called an embryo and begins developing further. This is point where the primitive streak appears and at which time gastrulation begins meaning the pre-embryo entity transforms from a one-dimensional layer of epithelial cells (blastula) and reorganizes into a multilayered and multidimensional structure called the gastrula. Twinning can no longer occur.
Technically, the first two weeks of pregnancy is referred to as the germinal or pre-embryonic stage, although colloquially many use the term embryo to refer to all the pre-fetal stages. During the following eight-week period, the embryo develops the head, spine and internal organs. At that point, the entity is called a fetus slowly emerging as the blueprint for a single individualized person to be born at the end of a successful pregnancy.
It appears, then, that the 14-day rule does have a biological basis which transcends the two features cited by Warnock: the moral grounds of sentience and individuality; and the technical infeasibility of cultivating embryos in-lab that has existed until recently. Clear biological staging and developmental criteria are triggered at this stage in development.
Still, the prime question remains unresolved: While technology has now made extending the time to experiment possible, just because we can, doesnt automatically mean we should. A major problem is that the community of stakeholders are using terms differently. The legal (and popular) definition of an embryo differs depending on who you ask, which might contribute to the confusion and surely impacts the solution. In a definition only a lawyer (or philosopher) could love, countries with strict embryo laws define an embryo as a cell or cluster of cells with the potential to grow into a human being, thereby obfuscating and ignoring long-accepted biological benchmarks.
How do we resolve these competing complex concepts? The 14-week rule could be extended on a case-by-case basis, although that wouldnt address the moral or religious concerns (e.g., when is a developing embryo a person?) nor the biological ones. If there is a biological, bright-line divide, it is unlikely to occur at arbitrary points of time, such as 14 or 28 days.
Recent advancements may offer a way out of this conundrum. Non-egg sperm constructs, called organoids, have been developed from stem cells and are being used for research on prenatal development. Stem cells are undifferentiated cells with the potential to develop into a line of tissues or even organs. As opposed to embryos which have the potential to develop into a complete human, the potential for stem cell development is far more limited, and so can be seen as morally safer.
Other means of developing test models involve synthetic human entities with embryo-like features (called SHEEFs or synthetic human entities with embryo-like features) and some forms oforganoids(i.e., miniature 3D tissue models of organs). These models have developed synthetic embryos with the capacity to develop further although so far, theyve only been developed in mice.
Experiments on these synthetic embryos (contrived without egg or sperm) appear to bypass the objections raised in extending the 14-day rule, although they may generate ethical dilemmas of their own (a discussion for another day). So, experimenting on SHEEFS could provide similar knowledge gleaned from experimenting on one-month-old embryos, making research up to the 28-day-old limit unnecessary, and thereby obviating the dilemma.
Yet some scientists and ethicists are using the possibility of experimenting on these SHEEFS, lets call this point A, as a basis to advocate extension of the 14-day rule, point B. Im not sure how they get from point A to point B. I can only surmise that these advocates dont understand the legalities or moralities involved in experimenting on a human embryo.
Barbara Pfeffer Billauer,JD MA (Occ. Health) Ph.D. is Professor of Law and Bioethics in the International Program in Bioethics of the University of Porto and Research Professor of Scientific Statecraft at the Institute of World Politics in Washington DC.
- Politics of Stem Cell Research - May 7th, 2011 [May 7th, 2011]
- Obama Ends Funding Ban for Stem Cell Research - May 8th, 2011 [May 8th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research: A Father's Fight - May 10th, 2011 [May 10th, 2011]
- Human Embryonic stem cell research - May 11th, 2011 [May 11th, 2011]
- Frost Over The World - Stem Cell Research and Turkey -26 Oct - May 20th, 2011 [May 20th, 2011]
- McCain Favors Embryonic Stem Cell Research - May 20th, 2011 [May 20th, 2011]
- US divided over stem cell research reversal - 09 Mar 09 - May 21st, 2011 [May 21st, 2011]
- The Politics and Promise of Stem Cell Research - May 22nd, 2011 [May 22nd, 2011]
- Inside Story - Obama to end stem cell research ban - March 9 - Part1 - May 30th, 2011 [May 30th, 2011]
- Cardiovascular Therapies: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Douglas Boyd - June 3rd, 2011 [June 3rd, 2011]
- The Human Embryo and Embryonic Stem Cell Biology: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - June 3rd, 2011 [June 3rd, 2011]
- US appeals court lifts stem cell research ban - June 7th, 2011 [June 7th, 2011]
- Trailer for Mapping Stem Cell Research: Terra Incognita - June 9th, 2011 [June 9th, 2011]
- Politics: President Obama on Stem Cell Research - June 10th, 2011 [June 10th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research Documentary - June 11th, 2011 [June 11th, 2011]
- TEDxSingapore - Susan Lim - Hype and hope of stem cell research - June 13th, 2011 [June 13th, 2011]
- Lou Gehrig's Disease (ALS): Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Wrapup - June 14th, 2011 [June 14th, 2011]
- The Next Frontier in Stem Cell Research - June 17th, 2011 [June 17th, 2011]
- Robert Klein: Stem Cell Research - June 22nd, 2011 [June 22nd, 2011]
- Fibrocell Stem-Cell Wrinkle Smoother Wins FDA Clearance - June 23rd, 2011 [June 23rd, 2011]
- The Politics of Stem Cell Research - June 23rd, 2011 [June 23rd, 2011]
- A Dose of Reality on Alternative Stem Cell Treatments: What you don't know can hurt you - June 28th, 2011 [June 28th, 2011]
- Governor Tim Pawlenty Discusses Stem Cell Research - June 30th, 2011 [June 30th, 2011]
- The EU and stem cell research - July 5th, 2011 [July 5th, 2011]
- Parkinson's Disease: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Jeff Bronstein - July 6th, 2011 [July 6th, 2011]
- Cardiovascular Therapies: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Yung-Wei Chi - July 7th, 2011 [July 7th, 2011]
- Spotlight on Cancer Stem Cell Research - July 11th, 2011 [July 11th, 2011]
- A Stem Cell Story - July 12th, 2011 [July 12th, 2011]
- Bishop Blair bars support for Komen breast cancer group - July 13th, 2011 [July 13th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research In Toronto - July 14th, 2011 [July 14th, 2011]
- Arthritis: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Introduction - July 14th, 2011 [July 14th, 2011]
- Huntington's Disease: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research 2007 - Han Keirstead - July 15th, 2011 [July 15th, 2011]
- TMconfUK2011-08 - Stem Cell Research in the UK - Prof Charles Ffrench-Constant - July 16th, 2011 [July 16th, 2011]
- UCSF opens stem cell research building - July 16th, 2011 [July 16th, 2011]
- HIV/AIDS: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - John Zaia - July 17th, 2011 [July 17th, 2011]
- Deafness: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Ebenezer Yamoah - July 22nd, 2011 [July 22nd, 2011]
- Spotlight on Basic Stem Cell Research - Irv Weissman - July 25th, 2011 [July 25th, 2011]
- Diabetes: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Peter Butler - July 27th, 2011 [July 27th, 2011]
- Parkinson's Disease: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Arnold Kriegstein - July 27th, 2011 [July 27th, 2011]
- HIV/AIDS: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Loren Leeds - July 27th, 2011 [July 27th, 2011]
- Alzheimer's Disease: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Leeza Gibbons - August 2nd, 2011 [August 2nd, 2011]
- Geron's Embryonic Stem Cell Clinical Trial for Spinal Cord Injury - August 3rd, 2011 [August 3rd, 2011]
- The Skin Gun stem cell research - August 10th, 2011 [August 10th, 2011]
- Deafness: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Karen Doyle - August 10th, 2011 [August 10th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research: Huntington's Disease - August 14th, 2011 [August 14th, 2011]
- Adult and Non-Embryonic Stem Cell Research Conference at Notre Dame - August 20th, 2011 [August 20th, 2011]
- Stemcell Research and Aging - Panel 1 - August 22nd, 2011 [August 22nd, 2011]
- Texans for Stem Cell Research Learn for Life: KXAN Coverage Aired August 16th, 2011 - August 24th, 2011 [August 24th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research: Macular Degeneration - September 18th, 2011 [September 18th, 2011]
- Brilliant Minds - Stem Cell Research | Tomorrow Today - September 25th, 2011 [September 25th, 2011]
- Ethics of Stem Cell Research (1) - September 29th, 2011 [September 29th, 2011]
- Legal and Public Policy Dimensions of Stem Cell Research - September 29th, 2011 [September 29th, 2011]
- Stem cell symposium - October 2nd, 2011 [October 2nd, 2011]
- StemCONN 2011, The Latest in Stem Cell Research - October 6th, 2011 [October 6th, 2011]
- Arthritis: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - Mark Genovese - October 7th, 2011 [October 7th, 2011]
- Judy Roberson: Patient advocates drive stem cell scientists - October 8th, 2011 [October 8th, 2011]
- Sam Harris - Stem Cells and Morality - October 8th, 2011 [October 8th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research, Ethics and Religion - October 9th, 2011 [October 9th, 2011]
- Stem Cells: Fulfilling the Promise - 2011 CIRM Grantee Meeting - October 10th, 2011 [October 10th, 2011]
- The Skin Gun (Stem Cell research to replace burnt off skin. Done in 3 days!) - October 13th, 2011 [October 13th, 2011]
- Alzheimer's Stem Cell Research Patient Advocate Spotlight: The Faces of Neurodegenerative Disease - Video - October 18th, 2011 [October 18th, 2011]
- Life in the Balance: Perspectives on Stem Cell Research - Video - October 18th, 2011 [October 18th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research Funding Halt - Video - October 19th, 2011 [October 19th, 2011]
- Vatican lending hand in adult stem cell research - Video - October 20th, 2011 [October 20th, 2011]
- First Spinal-Cord Surgery With Stem Cells - Video - October 21st, 2011 [October 21st, 2011]
- Michael J. Fox Embryonic Stem Cell Research - Video - October 22nd, 2011 [October 22nd, 2011]
- stem cell research - Video - October 22nd, 2011 [October 22nd, 2011]
- Gayle Atteberry - Cloning - November 5th, 2011 [November 5th, 2011]
- It Takes Nerve: UC Irvine - Sue - November 6th, 2011 [November 6th, 2011]
- Embryonic Stem Cell Research - Video - November 9th, 2011 [November 9th, 2011]
- Adult Stem Cell Research Far Ahead of Embryonic - Video - November 10th, 2011 [November 10th, 2011]
- Is stem cell research a growing concern .flv - Video - November 10th, 2011 [November 10th, 2011]
- Forbes Discusses Stem Cell Research - Video - November 14th, 2011 [November 14th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research Presentation - Video - November 16th, 2011 [November 16th, 2011]
- Benedict XVI: No embryonic stem cell research - Video - November 28th, 2011 [November 28th, 2011]
- Batten Disease: Spotlight on Stem Cell Research - A Father's Story - Video - November 30th, 2011 [November 30th, 2011]
- CIS 111 Digital Media Project - Stem Cell Research - Video - December 13th, 2011 [December 13th, 2011]
- Regenerative Medicine and Applications of Stem Cell Research - Video - December 20th, 2011 [December 20th, 2011]
- Stem Cell Research Today: Larry Goldstein - CIRM Science Writer's Seminar - Video - December 22nd, 2011 [December 22nd, 2011]
- CIRM Bridges Award: Building California's Stem Cell Research Workforce - Video - December 22nd, 2011 [December 22nd, 2011]