The recent article, Unprocessed Red Meat and Processed Meat Consumption: Dietary Guideline Recommendations from the NutriRECS Consortium, by B. Johnston, et.al., published Oct. 1 in the Annals of Internal Medicine certainly made a big splash in the news. The reason for the large media coverage is due to its literature review of red and unprocessed meat consumption and determining that meats association with death from cancer, heart disease or diabetes is low. This assessment has led to headlines proclaiming consumption of red and processed meat as safe.
Major health organizations and leading nutrition researchers have long recommended limiting red and processed meat consumption to reduce risk of these diseases. Why the controversy? Lets assess how the new study was conducted and see where the differences arise.
What the Study Assessed
The study reviewed randomized and observational research of meat and processed meat consumption on cardiometabolic and cancer outcomes published through 2018. The authors only looked at studies of greater than 1,000 or more adults and those that ran 6 months or longer. They also looked at published research on the subjects health-related values and preferences related to this consumption. They decided 3 servings a week as a realistic reduction. They used GRADEpro software to rank the articles using a of panel of experts in health research, nutritional epidemiology, dietetics, family and internal medicine and three public members. However, they do not list the names of this panel nor credentials.
Acknowledged Study Limitations
Not widely covered in the media is some of the study limitations the authors discussed. They found most diet pattern studies did not typically report separate data for red and processed meat consumption. They also noted other food and nutrient characteristics varied widely across studies. They could not conduct any analysis of meat preparation differences, such as baking or boiling versus grilling or broiling the latter are known to create cancer-causing heterocylic amines or HCAs, especially when the meat is charred. HCAs are chemicals that are formed when muscle meat like beef, chicken or pork is cooked using high temperature methods such as grilling. The authors also state they did not address the personal ethical preferences and the significant contribution meat production has on global warming.
Other Major Study Limitations
The study never defined what a serving of meat is. According to USDAs MyPlate, 5-7 ounces of protein is needed daily, and the serving size for protein group foods is 1 ounce. Most registered dietitians define a typical portion size (amount of food you eat) from the protein group as 3 ounces. What people really consume at one time greatly varies, with restaurant portions of meat averaging 6-12 ounces. Besides not addressing meat preparation, no analysis was conducted on the cuts of meat, detailing the amount of saturated fat, sodium and calories. This is highly variable, especially in processed meats. For example, bacon and sausage have a high amount of saturated fat and sodium per serving, versus pork loin.
The study did not address the total diet composition of saturated fat, sodium, carbohydrates and food groups. Any registered dietitian can tell you the entire diet needs to be analyzed and compared to these disease risks, not one food. We dont just eat one food or nutrient, so any realistic comparison to disease outcomes needs to take the whole diet approach. There are numerous randomized studies that show that following the Mediterranean diet and DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension) diet, for example, lowers blood pressure, LDL cholesterol, controls diabetes, and helps prevent and control heart disease, many cancers, obesity and other chronic diseases.
As discussed in the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, males aged 14-70 average an excess of 7-15 ounces above the recommended 23-31 ounces per week of lean meats, poultry and eggs, based on 1,800-2,600 kcal needs (Healthy US Style and Mediterranean Eating Patterns). The eating patterns of teen boys and men demonstrate the need for them to shift to consuming more seafood, and plant proteins and reduce animal protein intake, as recommended in the Dietary Guidelines for Americans. In this study, assessing a limit of 3 servings of red or processed meats a week is low for this group, and is a good goal. The article also incorrectly stated the Dietary Guidelines for Americans as recommending one serving of meat per week; it is one serving of lean meat, poultry, or eggs per day.
The study did not assess how much fish, nuts, seeds, soy products, low or high fat dairy or legumes as other protein sources were consumed. Americans are averaging one-half of what is recommended of these plant proteins and fish, especially for ages 14-30, and often meat is displacing these important heart-healthy foods. These amounts would also need to be assessed as a part of the total diet to determine cardiovascular risk and controlled.
It is interesting to note the authors took a population based approached to the study, yet directly noted their assessment is applicable to all individuals. Registered dietitians individualize diet recommendations based on medical diagnosis, medications, laboratory work, personal and cultural preferences. As noted above, certain sex and age groups overconsume meat, poultry and eggs, for example and have varying caloric needs. Lumping all ages and sexes together in this analysis and making a blanket meat consumption safety recommendation cannot be valid for all.
The study curiously excluded research of less than 1,000 subjects per study, and those less than 6 months in duration. There is no explanation why. This excludes a large amount of studies from their analysis, so makes it incomplete. It also lumps together large observational studies, with cannot assess cause and effect, with randomized controlled studies.
In a major review article or any published research, the reader needs to consider any potential conflict of interest by the authors. In the authors disclosure they did not report accepting money from the meat industry, as reported by New York Times and Healthline. The study was funded by the International Life Sciences Institute, an industry trade group. These facts and their nondisclosure make the entire analysis more suspect and potentially biased.
In summary, there is good reason the American Heart Association, American Cancer Society, American Institute for Cancer Research, researchers from the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, and registered dietitians have complained about this review study and its significant limitations. Following the Mediterranean, DASH, and Healthy US Style Eating Patterns as recommended by these leading health organizations and nutrition professionals is still a valid, research and evidenced based good idea. Contact a registered dietitian for a more individualized eating plan and diet recommendations.
Original post:
Red and Processed Meat Diet Recommendation Review | Health & Safety - Lancaster Farming
- Heart Disease - April 10th, 2018 [April 10th, 2018]
- Heart and Cardiovascular Research - April 10th, 2018 [April 10th, 2018]
- Heart and Cardiovascular Research - iMedPub - May 22nd, 2018 [May 22nd, 2018]
- Heart Disease - A Closer Look at Stem Cell Treatments - May 27th, 2018 [May 27th, 2018]
- Heart Conferences | Heart Congress | Cardiology ... - June 26th, 2018 [June 26th, 2018]
- Heart disease - Symptoms and causes - Mayo Clinic - September 21st, 2018 [September 21st, 2018]
- Diabetes, Heart Disease, and Stroke | NIDDK - September 29th, 2018 [September 29th, 2018]
- Heart Diseases & Disorders - Heart Rhythm Society - October 31st, 2018 [October 31st, 2018]
- Heart Disease - Closer Look at Stem Cells - November 15th, 2018 [November 15th, 2018]
- What is Heart Disease?, HHS, NIH, NHLBI - December 28th, 2018 [December 28th, 2018]
- Types of Heart Disease | Covenant HealthCare - December 30th, 2018 [December 30th, 2018]
- Heart Disease - Lab Tests Online - December 30th, 2018 [December 30th, 2018]
- Heart Diseases | Genetic and Rare Diseases Information Center ... - December 30th, 2018 [December 30th, 2018]
- Heart Healthy Lifestyle - Prevent Heart Diseases - HeartCare - January 26th, 2019 [January 26th, 2019]
- Breast cancer most prevalent in Sabah - The Borneo Post - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Menopause and womens heart health - Udaipur Kiran - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Low Birth Weight Linked To Heart Problems In Adulthood: Study - News Nation - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Consuming Red Meat And Pork Linked To Heart Disease And Cancer - Peoria Observer - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Yes, we still need to cut down on red and processed meat - The Conversation AU - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- On oral contraceptive pills? You could be at risk of heart disease! - Times Now - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Rutgers researchers find heart valve infections increasing in hospitals - RU Daily Targum - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Most common warning symptoms of heart attack - Elets - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Adults Who Lost Teeth More Prone to Heart Attack, Stroke - SciTechDaily - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Heart and Stroke Foundation: 80% of heart attacks, strokes can be prevented - Northern Natal Courier - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Heart diseases on the rise: experts - newagebd.net - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Heart attack: Best diet to protect against the life-threatening condition - Express - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Women 'suffering and dying' because of inequalities in heart disease diagnosis and treatment - Holyrood - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- B'luru's air pollution contributing to heart diseases? Study finds drivers are at risk - The News Minute - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Alia Bhatt supports fundraising for kids with heart diseases: They are more positive than adults - India Today - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Reduce heart disease at the American Heart Associations Heart Walk - KXAN.com - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Losing teeth may not be a good sign, could be indicative of heart disease risk - Economic Times - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Tooth Loss Associated with Higher Risk of Heart Disease - Cath Lab Digest - October 6th, 2019 [October 6th, 2019]
- Heart failure is the silent killer you've been ignoring - Times of India - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- FDA awards 12 grants to fund new clinical trials to advance the development of medical products for the treatment of rare diseases - FDA.gov - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Daikon Radish: Types, Nutrition, Benefits, and Uses - Healthline - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Air Pollution May Affect Every Organ, Cell in the Body - Voice of America - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Less than 6 hours of sleep a night linked to increased risk of early death - NHS Website - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Disabled mum left in tears after DWP wrongly stopped all her benefits - Mirror Online - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- How to live longer: Best diet to boost your life expectancy - what to eat - Express - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Men Should Stop Drinking Six Months In Advance If They Plan to Be Fathers - AskMen - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Dr. Roach: Assessing the risks of secondhand cigarette smoke - The Detroit News - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- What is vascular disease? - Midland Daily News - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Fauna Bio Receives Grant From the National Institutes of Health to Advance Its Drug Repurposing Platform - BioSpace - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Bacon rashers, statistics, and controversy - The BMJ - The BMJ - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Why should you have semolina (suji) for weight loss - Times of India - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- 4 blind spots in the confusing debate about red meat - Inverse - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Inflammation Signs That Are Often Overlooked - msnNOW - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- MKRMS seminar: Experts stress regular exercise, healthy food for heart health - The News International - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Exercise, healthy food for heart health stressed - The News International - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- AstraZeneca HealthCare Foundation Awards $775000 to 11 Innovative Heart Health Programs & Announces Open Call for Applications - Business Wire - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- How to live longer: The superfood proven to boost brain and heart health - Express - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- People with mental disorder at high risk of heart diseases - Yahoo India News - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Do Women Need To Worry About Heart Disease? - Version Weekly - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Stroke rates continue decline in the U.S. - Reuters - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- 6 Foods That Can Help Protect You Against Life-Threatening Ailments - International Business Times - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Prevention of Heart Disease - The Sentinel Assam - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Tooth loss linked to higher risk of heart disease - The New Indian Express - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Performing HIIT Exercises Can Help Minimize The Risk Of Contracting A Heart Disease - International Business Times - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Heart disease: Best exercise to lower the risk of developing the deadly condition - Express - October 10th, 2019 [October 10th, 2019]
- Shropshire people left more than 343000 in wills to British Heart Foundation - shropshirestar.com - October 11th, 2019 [October 11th, 2019]
- Queen's Speech puts air pollution, science and the NHS on the agenda - British Heart Foundation - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- In a rural Wisconsin village, the doctor makes house calls and sees some of the rarest diseases on Earth - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Treatment And Management Of Heart Disease During Pregnancy - Version Weekly - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Severe dental diseases persist in S.D. due to chronic poverty and lack of access to dentists - KELO AM-FM - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- New York Ranks 25th In Nation In First-Ever Childhood Obesity Study - WAER - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Saddleridge Fire Leads to Poor Air Quality, Tips on Staying Healthy - NBC Southern California - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- This country just became the first to ban ads for sugary drinks - WGAL Lancaster - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Heart disease: Three dietary tips to keep the risks at bay - Express - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Eating habits that can reverse heart disease - Daily Monitor - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Hale and hearty: Tips to maintain good heart health - The New Indian Express - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Exercise Is Especially Important For Those With Heart Disease - Anti Aging News - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Exercise good for people with heart disease, other physical ailments - Al Bawaba - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Should you eat red meat or not? A dietitian explains the latest nutrition science on meat, eggs and butter - NBC News - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- Rheumatic heart disease in Northern Territory 'a bloody health emergency' - The Guardian - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- PPMD Grants to Promote Gene Therapy for Heart Disease and Patient Outcomes Research - Muscular Dystrophy News - October 15th, 2019 [October 15th, 2019]
- University of Guelph researchers track how cats' weights change over time - Jill Lopez - October 20th, 2019 [October 20th, 2019]
- Study Shows That a 50% Pay Raise Lowers the Risk of Cardiovascular Diseases by 15% - WORLD OF BUZZ - October 20th, 2019 [October 20th, 2019]
- Dog owners less likely to have cardiovascular diseases, and better chances of recovering from strokes or heart - MEAWW - October 20th, 2019 [October 20th, 2019]
- Keep your heart pumping - The New Indian Express - October 20th, 2019 [October 20th, 2019]
- How Can We Curb the Spread of Scientific Racism? - Scientific American - October 20th, 2019 [October 20th, 2019]