Calling the draft surrogacy Bill narrow, the parliamentary committee has recommended allowing live-in couples, divorced women and widows to use surrogates, adding that a surrogate should not have to belong to the parents family.
The committee has said that purely altruistic surrogacy will infringe on the surrogates rights. Credit: Reuters
New Delhi:Criticising the Centres draft Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016 for having a narrow understanding of Indian society and playing into patriarchal assumptions, the parliamentary panel that was set up to look into the Bills provisions and speak to experts in the field has recommended broadening the Bills purview and a more liberal surrogacy framework in an 88-page report.
No such thing as purely altruistic surrogacy
The original Bill wanted to do away with commercial surrogacy and instead base it on altruism. The surrogate has to be a close relative of the married couple in question (who must be infertile, of Indian origin, married for at least five years and between 23-50 for women and 26-55 for men years of age). A woman can act as a surrogate only once, the Bill said, while she is between 25 and 35 years of age.
This definition of altruistic surrogacy, the 31-member has said in its report, cannot work in a patriarchal structure. The surrogate is likely to be coerced and will get nothing out of this arrangement, while everyone else will benefit, reinforcing the idea that a womans body is not her own.
Pregnancy is not a one minute job but a labour of nine months with far reaching implications regarding her health, her time and her family. In the altruistic arrangement, the commissioning couple gets a child; and doctors, lawyers and hospitals get paid. However, the surrogate mothers are expected to practice altruism without a single penny.
The Committee, therefore, finds merit in the argument that the proposed altruistic surrogacy is far removed from the ground realities. The Committee is, therefore, of the view that expecting a woman, that too, a close relative to be altruistic enough to become a surrogate and endure all hardships of the surrogacy procedure in the pregnancy period and post partum period is tantamount to a another form of exploitation.
The Bill limits the circle of choosing a surrogate mother from within close relatives. Given the patriarchal familial structure and power equations within families, not every member of a family has the ability to resist a demand that she be a surrogate for another family member. A close relative of the intending couple may be forced to become a surrogate which might become even more exploitative than commercial surrogacy. The Committee, therefore, firmly believes that altruistic surrogacy only by close relatives will always be because of compulsion and coercion and not because of altruism.
The committee hailed the fact that regulation was need in the surrogacy sector, given the economic and social power imbalance that exists between the actors in most cases, but said the regulations should be of a different kind than what is suggested in the Bill, like authorities fixing the compensation amount to be paid to a surrogate and making sure that payments begin the moment the process is started. The panel agrees that no women should be a surrogate more than once surrogacy cannot be a way out for women opting for surrogacy due to poverty and should not be allowed as a profession.
Shouldnt be limited to married couples
The provision that only Indian couples who have been married for at least five years can avail of a surrogate overlooks a large section of society, the panel has argued.
The Department of Health Research by imposing prohibition on widows and divorced women seems to have closed its eyes to the ground reality. Besides, the decision to keep live-in partners out of the purview of the Bill is indicative of the fact that the Bill is not in consonance with the present day modern social milieu that we live in and is too narrow in its understanding. Even the Supreme Court has given a legal sanctity to live-in relationships. Surrogacy is one of the least used options by childless Indians. If all these categories are to be banned then why have surrogacy at all. The Committee, therefore, recommends that the Department should broadbase the eligibility criteria in this regard and widen the ambit of persons who can avail surrogacy services by including live-in couples, divorced women/ widows.
The report also recommends doing away with the five-year waiting period meant for couples to avail all assisted reproductive techniques to have a child of their own, saying it does not make sense as the couples involved may already be in their 30s and 40s. This waiting period is also inconsistent with the WHOs definition of infertility, the committee has argued, which defines infertility as the inability to conceive after at least one year of unprotected coitus.
The committee stood by the provision that surrogacy be limited to Indian citizens, saying foreigners only come to India to find surrogates because it is much cheaper here.
One of the other criticisms of the Bill was that it left out homosexual couples. But the report does not say anything about that.
Surrogates should not be limited to close family members
The Bills provision that a surrogate must a 25-35-year-old woman who is a close relative of the couple and has one child of her has been criticised by the committee on various grounds. For one, they have said the woman may be coerced into doing it by her family against her wishes. Two, the child and surrogate mother will be living in close proximity given the nature of Indian families, and this could have a detrimental impact on both their mental heath. Three, most nuclear families may find it hard to find someone in their family who fits all the criteria. Four, couples who want to keep the surrogacy private wont have that option and will be forced to tell their families, despite the social taboos involved. Given all of this,
The Committee is convinced that limiting the practice of surrogacy to close relatives is not only non pragmatic and unworkable but also has no connect with the object to stop exploitation of surrogates envisaged in the proposed legislation. The Committee, therefore, recommends that this clause of close relative should be removed to widen the scope of getting surrogate mothers from outside the close confines of the family of intending couple. In fact, both related and unrelated women should be permitted to become a surrogate.
Surrogacy is not regulated in India yet. Credit: Reuters
Finding non-existent doctors
One of the committees other recommendations is based on the Bills definition of a human embryologist. According to the Bill, human embryologist means a person who possesses any post-graduate medical qualification in the field of human embryology recognized under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 or who possesses a post-graduate degree in human embryology from a recognized university with not less than two years of clinical experience. However, the committee has noted in its report, no such post-graduate degree in human embryology is offered at an Indian university, so this definition mustbe rephrased so people know what sort of specialty doctors they should be consulting. As it stands now,
The Committee fails to understand how the Department would utilize the services of such specialty doctors in every corner of the country when these doctors do not exist.
Keeping track of cases
In order to make sure that regulations around surrogacy are followed, the committee has recommended the creation of a national database where surrogacy cases are tracked from start to finish.
Having a centralized database at the National level would be a step in right direction so as to monitor the surrogates, surrogacy clinics and the commissioning parents. All State Surrogacy Boards should be required to submit to the National Surrogacy Board, data on the surrogacy services and arrangements. Therefore, the Committee is in unison with the suggestion of keeping a registry at the national level having details of the registration and conduct of every surrogacy clinic, surrogacy arrangements, including its stakeholders, taking place across the country. Such a registry will also help in tracking the surrogate mothers who will act as surrogate only once in their lifetime
What to read next:
See more here:
Surrogacy Bill Should Be Broadened, Include Compensation, Says Parliamentary Panel - The Wire
- Embryology Part 2 - Video - January 2nd, 2013 [January 2nd, 2013]
- Copy of INTRO TO HUMAN EMBRYOLOGY; PART 1 by Professor Fink - Video - February 1st, 2013 [February 1st, 2013]
- 14- The development of the vascular system - Video - January 23rd, 2014 [January 23rd, 2014]
- IVF treatment for single women DOUBLES as they give up search for Mr Right and go it alone instead - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Embryology - New World Encyclopedia - Info:Main Page - New ... - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Embryology - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- The Proof That Islam Is The Truth 07 Embryology - Video - April 10th, 2014 [April 10th, 2014]
- Does germ plasm accelerate evolution? - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- 4-H program teaches children science on spring break - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Embryology Video 15: Tongue formation - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Embryology In The Quran Amazing Reminder The Daily Reminder - Video - April 15th, 2014 [April 15th, 2014]
- Venous Embryology: Key to Understanding Truncular Venous Malformations - Video - April 18th, 2014 [April 18th, 2014]
- Eggciting Eggperience - April 19th, 2014 [April 19th, 2014]
- Private fertility clinics see rise in number of women freezing their eggs, but it's thought they have just EIGHT per ... - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- Dr Sherif Zaki Embryology (2) 17-4-2014 - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- Dr Sherif Zaki Embryology (1) 17-4-2014 - Video - April 21st, 2014 [April 21st, 2014]
- Oogenesis - Embryology - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 - Wikipedia ... - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- What is Embryology? (with picture) - wiseGEEK - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Cerebrospinal Fluid and Embryology - Video - April 22nd, 2014 [April 22nd, 2014]
- Pacific Fertility Center (PFC) to Present on Time-Lapse Imaging at ESHRE Annual Meeting - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Embryology 1 - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Embryology and Incubation: Hatching - Video - April 24th, 2014 [April 24th, 2014]
- Embryology - Video - April 25th, 2014 [April 25th, 2014]
- Embryology of Vascular system by Dr-Abdelfatah Aglan - Video - April 27th, 2014 [April 27th, 2014]
- The Divine Book Part 6 Amazing Human Embryology In The Quran - Video - April 28th, 2014 [April 28th, 2014]
- Embryology Of Heart by Dr Rania Aboelfdl - Video - April 28th, 2014 [April 28th, 2014]
- Warning: Senate Races Aren't as Close as They Appear - April 29th, 2014 [April 29th, 2014]
- Texas Fertility Center Opens New IVF Lab and Surgery Center in San Antonio - April 29th, 2014 [April 29th, 2014]
- Embryology In Quran - - Video - April 29th, 2014 [April 29th, 2014]
- Letters to the editor 5/1/14 - May 2nd, 2014 [May 2nd, 2014]
- Love-split lesbians fight custody battle over twins, 5, with THREE mothers - May 3rd, 2014 [May 3rd, 2014]
- Embryology In The Quran (Zakir Naik) - Video - May 3rd, 2014 [May 3rd, 2014]
- Dr Sherif Zaki Embryology (3) 30-4-2014 - Video - May 3rd, 2014 [May 3rd, 2014]
- Embryology - GAMETOGENESIS Part 3 - Video - May 4th, 2014 [May 4th, 2014]
- Dr Sherif Zaki Embryology (4) 4-5-2014 - Video - May 6th, 2014 [May 6th, 2014]
- 7 [Embryology] The Proof That Islam Is The Truth [Abdur Raheem Green] - Video - May 8th, 2014 [May 8th, 2014]
- Embryology - Haid 4th - Video - May 9th, 2014 [May 9th, 2014]
- Embryology - SPERMATOGENESIS - Video - May 9th, 2014 [May 9th, 2014]
- Embryology - the Beginning of human development "first week" - Video - May 12th, 2014 [May 12th, 2014]
- Embryology Final Video Project - Video - May 12th, 2014 [May 12th, 2014]
- Embryology - Formation of The Bilaminar Embryonic Disc "second week" - Video - May 12th, 2014 [May 12th, 2014]
- David Cameron plays the Orange card - May 16th, 2014 [May 16th, 2014]
- Feathered lesson: Lone Rock students learn about embryology with chicks - May 18th, 2014 [May 18th, 2014]
- Embryology in the Quran Much Ado About Nothing Hamza Tzortzis Refuted YouTube - Video - May 18th, 2014 [May 18th, 2014]
- - Embryology In The Quran - Video - May 18th, 2014 [May 18th, 2014]
- [UTAU Release] Virtual Star Embryology [Amakune Ichigo ARIA] - Video - May 18th, 2014 [May 18th, 2014]
- Licence wait stalls work at IVF clinic - May 19th, 2014 [May 19th, 2014]
- USMLE Embryology Epispadias vs Hypospadias - Video - May 20th, 2014 [May 20th, 2014]
- GOP avoids past mistakes in Senate picks - May 21st, 2014 [May 21st, 2014]
- GOP Voters Reject Tea Party Candidates - May 21st, 2014 [May 21st, 2014]
- Embryology Development Rotation of the midgut - Video - May 21st, 2014 [May 21st, 2014]
- The Folding of the Embryo (Embryology Development) - Video - May 21st, 2014 [May 21st, 2014]
- Embryology development Foregut development - Video - May 22nd, 2014 [May 22nd, 2014]
- Embryology Development for Intestine formation - Video - May 22nd, 2014 [May 22nd, 2014]
- Scientists Are the Real ProphetsA Muslim Perspective-Part 1 - May 31st, 2014 [May 31st, 2014]
- Udupi: Dr Satish Adiga of Manipal University to get Sir C V Raman award - May 31st, 2014 [May 31st, 2014]
- Mothers of women with PCOS have increased risk of early death - May 31st, 2014 [May 31st, 2014]
- Professor selected for Sir C.V. Raman award - May 31st, 2014 [May 31st, 2014]
- ESHRE's 30th Annual Meeting - May 31st, 2014 [May 31st, 2014]
- Three-Parent Conception Helps Reduce Risk Of Inherited Mitochondrial Disease - June 4th, 2014 [June 4th, 2014]
- SPC Embryology - Video - June 4th, 2014 [June 4th, 2014]
- Three-parent embryo technique flouts global ethics says SPUC - June 4th, 2014 [June 4th, 2014]
- Fertility clinics are 'exploiting' some infertile women, claims IVF pioneer Lord Winston - June 18th, 2014 [June 18th, 2014]
- Science Project: Body Structures, Vestigial Organs, Embryology, and Descent with Modification - Video - June 22nd, 2014 [June 22nd, 2014]
- Ridgewood students get inside look at medical field - June 24th, 2014 [June 24th, 2014]
- Donor IVF baby who says 'I wish I'd never been born' - June 26th, 2014 [June 26th, 2014]
- Pacific Fertility Centers Clinical Laboratory Director Presents at Two International Scientific Meetings in May - June 27th, 2014 [June 27th, 2014]
- The outcome of fertility treatments using donor sperm is dependent on the quality of sperm - June 30th, 2014 [June 30th, 2014]
- Children born to women after fertility treatment at greater risk of psychiatric disorders - June 30th, 2014 [June 30th, 2014]
- No link between fertility drugs and breast, ovarian and uterine cancers - June 30th, 2014 [June 30th, 2014]
- Efficacy doubts over pre-IVF hysteroscopy - June 30th, 2014 [June 30th, 2014]
- Embryology and gross anatomy 1 - Video - June 30th, 2014 [June 30th, 2014]
- Freeze-storage egg banking for egg donation treatment - July 3rd, 2014 [July 3rd, 2014]
- Preconceptional factors in the prediction of fertility and the reproductive lifespan - July 3rd, 2014 [July 3rd, 2014]
- Most women are aware of oocyte freezing for social reasons - July 3rd, 2014 [July 3rd, 2014]
- Pregnancies following egg donation associated with more than 3-fold higher risk of hypertension - July 3rd, 2014 [July 3rd, 2014]
- Embryology & Fetal Development - Video - July 3rd, 2014 [July 3rd, 2014]
- One in 100 women having IVF - July 7th, 2014 [July 7th, 2014]
- Embryology lecture 2 - Video - July 7th, 2014 [July 7th, 2014]