A Google engineer who was fired for posting an online claim that womens biology makes them less able than men to work in technology jobs has charged that he is being smeared and is a victim of political correctness.
James Damore, 28, questioned the companys diversity policies and claimed that scientific data backed up his assertions. Google CEO Sundar Pichai wrote that Damores 3,300-word manifesto crossed the line by advancing harmful gender stereotypes in the workplace. Pichai noted that To suggest a group of our colleagues have traits that make them less biologically suited to that work is offensive and not OK.
Damore argued that many men in the company agreed with his sentiments. Thats not surprising, since the idea that women just cant hack it in math and science has been around for a very long time. It has been argued that womens lack of a math gene, their brain structures and their inherent psychological traits put most of them out of the game.
Some critics sided with Damore. For example, columnist Ross Douthat of the New York Times found his scientific arguments intriguing.
But are they? What are the real facts? We have been researching issues of gender and STEM (science, technology engineering and math) for more than 25 years. We can say flatly that there is no evidence that womens biology makes them incapable of performing at the highest levels in any STEM fields.
Many reputable scientific authorities have weighed in on this question, including a major paper in the journal Science debunking the idea that the brains of males and females are so different that they should be educated in single-sex classrooms. The paper was written by eight prominent neuroscientists, headed by professor Diane Halpern of Claremont McKenna College, past president of the American Psychological Association. They argue that There is no well-designed research showing that single-sex education improves students academic performance, but there is evidence that sex segregation increases gender stereotyping and legitimizes institutional sexism.
They add, Neuroscientists have found few sex differences in childrens brains beyond the larger volume of boys brains and the earlier completion of girls brain growth, neither of which is known to relate to learning.
Several major books have debunked the idea of important brain differences between the sexes. Lise Eliot, associate professor in the Department of Neuroscience at the Chicago Medical School, did an exhaustive review of the scientific literature on human brains from birth to adolescence. She concluded, in her book Pink Brain, Blue Brain, that there is surprisingly little solid evidence of sex differences in childrens brains.
Rebecca Jordan-Young, a sociomedical scientist and professor at Barnard College, also rejects the notion that there are pink and blue brains, and that the differing organization of female and male brains is the key to behavior. In her book Brain Storm: The Flaws in the Science of Sex Differences, she says that this narrative misunderstands the complexities of biology and the dynamic nature of brain development.
And happily, the widely held belief that boys are naturally better than girls at math and science is unraveling among serious scientists. Evidence is mounting that girls are every bit as competent as boys in these areas. Psychology professor Janet Hyde of the University of WisconsinMadison has strong U.S. data showing no meaningful differences in math performance among more than seven million boys and girls in grades 2 through 12.
Also, several large-scale international testing programs find girls closing the gender gap in math, and in some cases outscoring the boys. Clearly, this huge improvement over a fairly short time period argues against biological explanations.
Much of the data that Damore provides in his memo is suspect, outdated or has other problems.
In his July memo, titled Googles Ideological Echo Chamber: How bias clouds our thinking about diversity and inclusion, Damore wrote that women on average have more openness directed towards feelings and aesthetics rather than ideas. And he stated that women are more inclined to have an interest in people rather than things, relative to men.
Damore cites the work of Simon Baron-Cohen, who argues in his widely reviewed book The Essential Difference that boys are biologically programmed to focus on objects, predisposing them to math and understanding systems, while girls are programmed to focus on people and feelings. The British psychologist claims that the male brain is the systematizing brain while the female brain is the empathizing brain.
This idea was based on a study of day-old babies, which found that the boys looked at mobiles longer and the girls looked at faces longer. Male brains, Baron-Cohen says, are ideally suited for leadership and power. They are hardwired for mastery of hunting and tracking, trading, achieving and maintaining power, gaining expertise, tolerating solitude, using aggression and taking on leadership roles.
The female brain, on the other hand, is specialized for making friends, mothering, gossip and reading a partner. Girls and women are so focused on others, he says, that they have little interest in figuring out how the world works.
But Baron-Cohens study had major problems. It was an outlier study. No one else has replicated these findings, including Baron-Cohen himself. It is so flawed as to be almost meaningless. Why?
The experiment lacked crucial controls against experimenter bias and was badly designed. Female and male infants were propped up in a parents lap and shown, side by side, an active person or an inanimate object. Since newborns cant hold their heads up independently, their visual preferences could well have been determined by the way their parents held them.
There is much literature that flat-out contradicts Baron-Cohen's study, providing evidence that male and female infants tend to respond equally to people and objects, notes Elizabeth Spelke, co-director of Harvards Mind Brain Behavior Interfaculty Initiative. But media stories continue to promote the idea of very different brains on little evidence.
Damore also claims that women experience more stress and anxiety than men, and that This may contribute to the higher levels of anxiety women report on Googlegeist and to the lower number of women in high-stress jobs.
He implies that stress and anxiety are personality traits inherent in females, but more likely they are due to the pressures and discrimination women face on the job that men do not. For example, a 2008 report sponsored by major companies, The Athena Factor, found that women in high positions in male-dominated fields, such as tech, suffer harsher penalties than men when they slip up. Women dont get second chances. Men do.
One of the reports authors, Sylvia Ann Hewlett, founding president of the Center for Work-Life Policy in New York, notes in the Harvard Business Review that in tech firms, the way to get promoted is to do a diving catch. Some system is crashing in Bulgaria, so you get on the plane in the middle of the night and dash off and spend the weekend wrestling with routers and come back a hero.
But what if you dont make the catch? Women have a hard time taking on those assignments because you can dive and fail to catch. If a man fails, his buddies dust him off and say, It's not your fault; try again next time. A woman fails and is never seen again.
Add to that conundrum the fact that just getting in the door is harder for a woman than it is for a man.
Her resume may look exactly like his, but because her name is Mary and not John, she may not get a second look. A review of studies of U.S. decision makers who have the power to hire candidates found that clearly competent men were rated higher than equally competent women. This bias is especially rampant in the high-tech industry. One study, conducted by professors at Columbia, Northwestern and the University of Chicago, found that two-thirds of managers selected male job candidates, even when the men did not perform as well as the women on math problems that were part of the application process.
Throw in the facts that, according to research, competent men are seen as likeable, while competent women are seen as bitchy, that women get less credit for their accomplishments than men do, that men are often promoted on promise while women get elevated only on the basis of performance, and that sexual harassment is a constant problem for women in tech.
All of these are issues that males simply do not have to face. The anxiety gap exists for a reason, and it is not about biology.
Many of Damores controversial conclusions rest heavily on one recent study and much older, now-discredited research, ignoring reams of data that tell a very different story. The argument that men, especially affluent men, are more focused on their male breadwinner role than on their more female family roles, does not reflect either research data or observational data.
And they seem to have noticed. According to SmartAsset.com, in just the past year ... at least 17 big employers have either introduced or expanded paid-leave options for new dads. They include Hilton, Netflix, Spotify, Microsoft and Fidelity.
The rate of expansion is unprecedented, said Ellen Bravo, executive director of Family Values @ Work.
But many men who would opt for paternity leave hesitate, not because of innate biological dispositions, but because of fear of retribution. Cultural stereotypes exert a powerful effect, punishing men for the caring, family-oriented behavior that they desire. Damores article may make it even harder for such men to take the paternity leave they so clearly crave.
The recent history of Swedens legislation on paternity leave highlights dramatically the overwhelming role of cultural stereotypes on male parental behavior. Its not biology at work here, but laws mandating at least two months of the nations well-paid, 13-month parental leave exclusively for fathers that have created profound social change.
In perhaps the most striking example of social engineering, a new definition of masculinity is emerging, notes the New York Times. Birgitta Ohlsson, European affairs minister, put it this way: Machos with dinosaur values dont make the top-10 lists of attractive men in womens magazines anymore. Now men can have it all a successful career and being a responsible daddy. Its a new kind of manly. Its more wholesome.
Damore, on the other hand, argues for downplaying empathy in American companies.
Creating more dinosaurs doesnt seem like a healthy way to go.
Caryl Rivers and Rosalind C. Barnett are the authors of The Age of Longevity: Re-Imagining Tomorrow for Our New Long Lives (Rowman and Littlefield) and The New Soft War on Women: How the Myth of Female Ascendance Is Hurting Women, Men and Our Economy (Tarcher/Penguin). Barnett is a senior scientist at the Womens Studies Research Center at Brandeis University and received the 2013 Work Life Legacy Award from the Families and Work Institute. A professor of journalism at Boston University, Rivers was awarded the Helen Thomas Lifetime Achievement Award in 2007 from the Society of Professional Journalists for distinguished achievement in journalism, as well as a Gannett Freedom Forum Journalism Grant for research on media.
See the original post here:
We've studied gender and STEM for 25 years. The science doesn't support the Google memo. - Recode
- Stanford Medicine magazine reports on the future of vision - Stanford Medical Center Report - August 25th, 2017
- OU Biology professor awarded grant for corneal research - News at OU - August 15th, 2017
- Geoengineering and Synthetic Biology - PLoS Blogs (blog) - August 15th, 2017
- The American Society for Cell Biology (ASCB) Appoints SPARGO, Inc. as Official Exposition and Advertising Sales and ... - Newswise (press release) - August 15th, 2017
- Alexion, Sema4 Partner on Rare Disease Diagnostics and Systems Biology - Drug Discovery & Development - August 15th, 2017
- Student-friendly, research-savvy new Biology Building opens its doors - Source - August 15th, 2017
- Nominations open for the PLOS Computational Biology Research Prize! - PLoS Blogs (blog) - August 15th, 2017
- How to Leverage the Biology of Healthy Leadership (And Why Leaders Have a Duty to Take Care of Themselves) - HuffPost - August 14th, 2017
- Google Manifesto: Does Biology Explain Gender Disparities in Tech? - Live Science - August 13th, 2017
- Sleep biology discovery could lead to new insomnia treatments that ... - UCLA Newsroom - August 13th, 2017
- Google worker says women don't advance in tech because of biology - CBS News - August 7th, 2017
- Researchers describe protein previously unknown in biology - Phys.Org - August 7th, 2017
- Can Buddhist Practices Help Us Overcome The Biological Pull Of Dissatisfaction? - NPR - August 7th, 2017
- The biology of color - Science Magazine - August 7th, 2017
- Thermo Fisher Scientific Advances Cryo-EM Leadership to Drive Structural Biology Discoveries - Markets Insider - August 7th, 2017
- Cell Atlases Reveal Biology's Frontiers - Quanta Magazine - July 12th, 2017
- CRISPR adds storing movies to its feats of molecular biology - Science News Magazine (blog) - July 12th, 2017
- Era of 'Biological Annihilation' Is Underway, Scientists Warn - New York Times - July 12th, 2017
- Biology test no longer required for high school diploma | The Seattle ... - The Seattle Times - July 12th, 2017
- Crowdfunding campaign supports biology field study - Cornell Chronicle - July 12th, 2017
- Synthetic Biology Advance May Put Microbiomes on the Clock - Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News - July 12th, 2017
- University of Vermont faculty win grant to explore biology major - vtdigger.org - July 12th, 2017
- Carbon nanotubes mimic biology - Phys.org - Phys.Org - July 12th, 2017
- SJW's Melt After Feminist YouTuber Tells Them Human Biology 101 - The Federalist - July 12th, 2017
- Sea Spiders Move Oxygen with Pumping Guts, Marine Biologists Say - Sci-News.com - July 12th, 2017
- Molecular Biology Enzymes and Kits and Reagents Market Worth $26.7 Billion by 2025: Grand View Research, Inc. - PR Newswire (press release) - June 29th, 2017
- Readers respond to climate activists, Washington's biology-test twist - Pacific Northwest Inlander - June 29th, 2017
- Chemists discover biology's version of the Friedel-Crafts alkylation - The Biological SCENE - June 29th, 2017
- SCOTUS just made a mockery of biology AND the Second Amendment - Conservative Review - June 28th, 2017
- Biology teacher is accused of soliciting sex with a teenager - Lexington Herald Leader - June 28th, 2017
- Biology professor Paul Sniegowski is named new Dean of the College - The Daily Pennsylvanian - June 27th, 2017
- Cancer studies pass reproducibility test - Science Magazine - June 27th, 2017
- WLU launching masters in biology programs - The Steubenville Herald-Star - June 26th, 2017
- Transgender Prejudice And The Belief In A Biological Basis For ... - NPR - June 26th, 2017
- Nixing state's biology exam results prudent - Walla Walla Union-Bulletin - June 26th, 2017
- Turkey pulls evolution from its high school curriculum - Ars Technica - June 26th, 2017
- NIMBioS: Mathematical Biology Tackles Destructive Plant Virus - Tennessee Today - June 23rd, 2017
- High schoolers may not need to pass biology test to graduate - The Daily Herald - June 23rd, 2017
- Combined molecular biology test is the first to distinguish benign ... - Medical Xpress - June 23rd, 2017
- Central Cabarrus teacher racks up awards doing something she loves - Independent Tribune - June 23rd, 2017
- Seniors who failed biology assessment test would get diplomas under new deal - The Spokesman-Review - June 22nd, 2017
- Beautycounter's scientists invented a moisturizer that mimics your skin's biology - Fast Company - June 22nd, 2017
- How the Biology in Every Single ALIEN Movie Fits Together - Nerdist - Nerdist - June 22nd, 2017
- WLU announces two new Biology programs | WTOV - WTOV Steubenville - June 22nd, 2017
- Open imaging data for biology - Phys.Org - June 22nd, 2017
- A Father-Son Bond, Born in Conservation Biology - SUNY Cortland News - June 22nd, 2017
- eils Krios microscope, opening new possibilities in biology research - Yale News - June 22nd, 2017
- Piecing together genetic histories of isolated populations - BMC Blogs Network (blog) - June 22nd, 2017
- Compromise on high school biology test passes first committee | The ... - The Spokesman-Review - June 21st, 2017
- 'Breatharian' couple magically defies biology, subsists only on clicks and BS - Mashable - June 21st, 2017
- UNF Spinnaker : Biology Professor Brews Up A Buzz - UNF Spinnaker - June 21st, 2017
- To connect biology with electronics, be rigid, yet flexible - Phys.org - Phys.Org - June 20th, 2017
- Biology teacher, Schreibvogel has wild side job | Local News ... - The Garden City Telegram - June 20th, 2017
- Biology Team Samples Drought-Tolerant Bacteria in Death Valley - Wesleyan Connection (blog) - June 20th, 2017
- The Maths of Life and Death: Our Secret Weapon in the Fight ... - Scientific American - June 18th, 2017
- Support Science Communication at Plant Biology 2017 - Biofortified Blog - June 17th, 2017
- Pierre Coulombe, Ph.D. to lead UM Department of Cell & Developmental Biology - University of Michigan Health System News (press release) - June 17th, 2017
- 'The cold biological truth is that sex changes are impossible,' says Camille Paglia - Washington Examiner - June 16th, 2017
- SUNY Potsdam biology professor warns motorists to watch for threatened turtles on North Country roadways - North Country Now - June 16th, 2017
- Rich Lenski elected associate member of the European Molecular Biology Organization - MSUToday - June 16th, 2017
- Local students wrap up a week of marine biology camp - WWSB ABC 7 - June 16th, 2017
- Senate would give high school seniors a break on biology test requirement - The Spokesman-Review - June 15th, 2017
- Five reasons we're excited by how structural biology is advancing cancer research - The Institute of Cancer Research (blog) - June 15th, 2017
- 18th International Congress of Developmental Biology (June 18 22, 2017): Hongyan Wang - PLoS Blogs (blog) - June 15th, 2017
- Revealing New Details of Cancer Biology with Automated Kinetic Live Cell Imaging - Bioscience Technology - June 15th, 2017
- Biology A-level students mark down exam board after yet another error - The Guardian - June 13th, 2017
- Leaving Cert biology: Incinerator and IVF on lively paper - Irish Times - June 13th, 2017
- 'Exciting biology' uncovers plants' high-fat diet for fungal benefactors - Phys.Org - June 13th, 2017
- The Exquisite Design of Human Biology - Discovery Institute - June 13th, 2017
- Retired biology professor's journey to carpet weaving - Daily Sabah - June 13th, 2017
- Synthetic Biology Expands and Grows - Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News - June 12th, 2017
- DePauw Mourns the Sudden Passing of Biology Prof. Bruce Serlin - DePauw University - June 12th, 2017
- UNCG biology research abuzz - UNCG Now - June 12th, 2017
- Uncovering the biology of a painful and disfiguring pediatric disease - Medical Xpress - June 12th, 2017
- The podocyte adhesome - Nature.com - June 12th, 2017
- Biology | Definition of Biology by Merriam-Webster - June 10th, 2017
- In Our View: Flunk Exam for Biology - The Columbian - June 10th, 2017
- CSU-Pueblo biology professor dies following crash - KKTV 11 News - June 10th, 2017
- Editorial: Kill biology, but don't undermine testing - The Spokesman-Review - June 10th, 2017
- FBI gets synthetic biology crash course at CSU - Source - June 10th, 2017