Try and avoid red meat. Its not good for you
This is advice most non-vegetarians have received and turns out the scientific data we have available doesnt support it. Researchers who reviewed various studies in scientific journals have concluded that there is no strong evidence linking red meat with cancers, heart disease and diabetes. A third review, in which scientists examined dietary guidelines for processed and unprocessed red meat, suggests adults can continue to consume them.
Annals of Internal Medicinepublished the three reviews, along with two more, all of which addressed health outcomes, including cancer, and dietary guidelines concerning the consumption of red meat. An independent group of clinical, nutritional and public health experts called NutriRECS, which specialises in conducting systematic reviews and framing practice guidelines, undertook the exercise.
The first one was concerned with the risk of developing heart disease, lifestyle-related diabetes, high blood pressure and cancer all conditions that experts have increasingly collected under the umbrella term of cardiometabolic illnesses. The researchers looked for clinical trials (published in multiple languages) to compare diets with different quantities of red meat, each differing by a gradient of at least one serving per week for six months or more. There were only a few such trials, and the reviewers found that most of them largely addressed only surrogate outcomes and with small differences in red meat consumption.
So the team concluded that there is low- to very-low-certainty evidence that suggests diets with smaller quantities of red meat may have little or no effect on heart or diabetes risks as well as on the incidence of cancer.
Also read:Check Your Vocabulary Before Using Coffee and Cancer in the Same Sentence
Our results from the evaluation of randomised trials do not support the recommendations in the United Kingdom, the United States or World Cancer Research Fund guidelines on red-meat intake, their paper reads. One could argue, however, that neither do they seriously challenge those recommendations. In other words, the advice to avoid red meat isnt founded on what we know.
As the paper added, Our results highlight the uncertainty regarding causal relationships between red meat consumption and major cardiometabolic and cancer outcomes.
For the second review, researchers scrutinised observational studies on links between reduced intake and processed meat intake and cancer mortality and incidence. They concluded that the studies suffered from biases thanks to limitations in the way they assessed peoples diets (including recall bias), how they adjusted for confounding factors and didnt have enough data for subgroup analyses.
The possible absolute effects of red and processed meat consumption on cancer mortality and incidence are very small, and the certainty of evidence is low to very low, the second paper said, much like the first.
The third review evaluated peoples health-related values and preferences, since they determine how much red meat they consume. Its corresponding paper said that again the evidence that non-vegetarians are attached to meat and are unwilling to change this behaviour when faced with potentially undesirable health effects is of low-certainty.
Thefourth reviewfound low-certainty evidence to suggests that omnivores are attached to meat and are more reluctant to change their eating habits, even in the face of well-grounded advice. The fifth offered a set of recommendations on eating red meat and processed meat based on its analysis, including suggesting that adults continue their extant diets containing unprocessed and processed red meat.
Several experts The Wire contacted agreed with the conclusions but not entirely with how the reviewers are interpreting them.
Anura Kurpad, a professor of physiology and nutrition at St Johns Medical College, Bengaluru, and a former president of the Nutrition Society of India, explained that the findings of the new reviews dont represent reversal of what we know but a reversal of interpretation and translation. The point was that the observed negative effects were small enough to translate into dont [worry] about this.
The finding is still that eating meat has a small risk. The interpretation is that the risk is small enough to ignore.
Also read:The Fat Lie Youve Been Told About Whats Hurting Your Heart
According to him, the reviews selected a few studies based on a criterion that is really very strict and more suited to drug trials. So a lot of observation studies that could also be informative fell through. They also didnt compare non-meat eaters or vegetarians to meat eaters, he said,indicating that the reviews would have been if the theyd looked at lower intakes or even zero intake as the base.
In other words, the reviewss conclusions are restricted by how the reviewers analysed them, and shouldnt change the way we think about modifying the amount of red meat we eat. Reducing dietary risk has always been an important nutritional goal, and it would be prudent to continue with what expertshave inferred from larger evaluations.
John Ioannidis, a professor of medicine at Stanford University, said, The numerical results practically are almost identical to what previous meta-analyses have shown: randomised trials show no health benefits and observational studies show no or small health benefits, and the evidence is of low quality.
The only difference, he continued, is the authors conclusion: that the evidence is of low quality and so one needs to be cautious, although he added they cannot make any strong recommendation. In contrast, the authors of previous studies have stressed the benefits of cutting back on red meat even if the evidence has been weak.
The methods of the Annals papers are very rigorous and clearly superior to what was done previously, according to Ioannidis, and that their conclusions are appropriate. Frederic Leroy, a professor at the department of industrial microbiology and food biotechnology at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel, agreed, saying the authors have performed a very rigorous quality check of the evidence based on the highest scientific standards.
And while the intentions of previous authors who recommended cutting down red meat may be good, it would be irresponsible for us to tell people that we know for sure that cutting back on red meat will save their lives.
In September this year, Leroy had reported that science doesnt yet support decisions about whether you should reduce your meat intake as well as that doing so could potentially be detrimental to public health, especially in certain vulnerable groups. Restricting the diet by taking away a valuable nutrient source needs careful planning, nutritional knowledge, and may not be for everyone, he explained, especially not when special needs are present, such as in the young and the elderly.
Also read: Wealthy Indians Must Eat Differently from Those Whose Rights They Defend
Indeed, his study as well as the reviews relate only to the health aspects. Other issues, such as environmental effects, ideological or religious concerns, and animal welfare aspects require another debate, where context and nuance are also often neglected, unfortunately, he said.
Most of the evidence that nutritionists have used to argue that people should eat less red meat and processed meat has come from observational studies. In these studies, scientists make note of how much meat the studies participants eat and then observe them for many years, recording the incidence of certain chronic diseases, like type-2 diabetes, and the mortality.
But this observation isnt direct, Most of it comes form participants through self-reported questionnaires, these questionnaires have beenknown to struggle to capture actual eating behaviour, Leroy said. Plus, health-conscious people in the West who report in these questionnaires are also more physically active, avoid cigarettes and alcohol; and have better access to healthcare. The observed associations tend to disappear or even reverse when research is done in non-Western settings.
This debate offers a nice example of the difference between what we want to believe and what we can really know, Ioannidis finished.
T.V. Padmais a freelance science journalist.
- 3 Reasons To Give Thanks For American Healthcare (Plus 3 Wishes And 3 Resolutions) - Forbes - December 2nd, 2019
- The Truth About Meat - Is it really destroying your health? - Your Local Guardian - December 2nd, 2019
- A Look at the Science Behind the CBD Gummies Hype - Baltimore Post-Examiner - December 2nd, 2019
- States With the Highest Rates of Alzheimer's Disease - KMVU Fox 26 Medford - December 2nd, 2019
- Health policies for the silver years - India Today - December 2nd, 2019
- Perth has not endured a heatwave in almost four years, but that could be about to change - ABC News - December 2nd, 2019
- Comment: At the heart of diabetes... - Gulf Digital News - December 2nd, 2019
- The Big Green Office Design Trend That Will Make Your Workers More Productive - Living Architecture Monitor magazine - December 2nd, 2019
- 'Heart heroes' launch campaign drive to tackle cardiovascular disease - Belfast Telegraph - November 27th, 2019
- Deportation fears linked to high blood pressure in women - KXLY Spokane - November 27th, 2019
- The states with the highest rates of Alzheimer's disease - Ladders - November 27th, 2019
- Sheffield research receives 800k to develop new gene therapy to treat CVD - News-Medical.net - November 27th, 2019
- Drinking These Many Cups Of Coffee Daily May Reduce The Risk Of Heart Problems; Study - NDTV Food - November 27th, 2019
- American Heart Association: Avoiding the Deadly Holiday Heart Attack - PRNewswire - November 27th, 2019
- Heart Attacks May Be Prevented With Help Of This Cooking Oil - International Business Times - November 27th, 2019
- Heart attack: This cooking oil has been proven to prevent the life-threatening condition - Express - November 27th, 2019
- Keep heart disease at bay with legume-rich diet - Times of India - November 27th, 2019
- Heart-Healthy Diet May Improve Brain And Memory Functioning; Study - NDTV Food - November 27th, 2019
- 5 Mediterranean Side Dishes to Give Thanksgiving a Healthy Flair - Healthline - November 27th, 2019
- Vaping and its Associated Diseases - News-Medical.net - November 27th, 2019
- Why You Should Add Rest to Your Workout Routine - TIME - November 27th, 2019
- Best Food for Heart Diseases: THESE food items can help you fight heart ailments - PINKVILLA - November 27th, 2019
- Alzheimer's treatments: What's on the horizon? - Tribune-Review - November 27th, 2019
- Teens too busy with their smartphones: Lack of exercise is making them obese & prone to heart disease - Economic Times - November 27th, 2019
- The only alternative to antibiotics for animals is disease prevention - Health Europa - November 23rd, 2019
- Researchers uncover critical role of PKM2 protein in multiple inflammatory diseases - News-Medical.net - November 23rd, 2019
- 11 Surprising Benefits and Uses of Black Rice - Healthline - November 7th, 2019
- Pro Soccer Players Have a Higher Risk of Developing Alzheimer's, Study Finds - Being Patient - November 7th, 2019
- Political parties must commit to tackling heart and circulatory diseases - British Heart Foundation - November 7th, 2019
- Going vegan in your seventies could ward off disease - Yahoo Sports - November 5th, 2019
- This is the 'biggest mistake' you can do while using air purifiers - Times of India - November 5th, 2019
- Mezzion Pharma announces Top Line Data from FUEL will be presented at the American Heart Association (AHA), Late Breaking Scientific Sessions, in... - November 5th, 2019
- Why Extra Virgin Olive Oil Is the Healthiest Fat on Earth - EcoWatch - November 5th, 2019
- Obesity in 7th graders increasing. What can parents do? - The Times Herald - November 5th, 2019
- What the toxic air did to Delhites - Down To Earth Magazine - November 5th, 2019
- Sleep And Alzheimer's: Cerebrospinal Fluid Washes Away Toxins : Shots - Health News - NPR - November 5th, 2019
- Hontiveros wants gov't to control prices of medicines - Manila Bulletin - November 5th, 2019
- Global Structural Heart Disease Treatment Devices Market Report to Share Key Aspects of the Industry with the details of Influence Factors - Market... - November 5th, 2019
- Regional health department head asks commissioners to ban smoking on county property - McCook Daily Gazette - November 5th, 2019
- Children in schools and daycares across Canada are exposed to unsafe water - Global News - November 5th, 2019
- Lower Physical Activity Leads To Higher Death Rates, Says Study; Here Are Some Clever Ways To Move More Throughout The Day - Doctor NDTV - November 5th, 2019
- Heart attack leading cause of death - The Star Online - November 2nd, 2019
- Obesity can have severe effects on cats - The Daily World - November 2nd, 2019
- Bulimia Is Associated With Increased Risk of Heart Diseases And Premature Death - International Business Times - November 2nd, 2019
- Every day is 'Diabetes Day' for thousands of Oklahomans - Tulsa World - November 2nd, 2019
- Air pollution contributing to increase in heart problems: Doctors - Hindustan Times - November 2nd, 2019
- Heart attacks leading cause of death in Malaysia - The Independent - November 2nd, 2019
- High blood pressure: Add this oil to your diet to lower your reading - Express - November 2nd, 2019
- A diet that's good for you is also good for the planetand vice versa - Anthropoce - November 2nd, 2019
- Fires and power outages show California isn't as special as we like to believe - Los Angeles Times - November 2nd, 2019
- Scientists find link between heart disease and cancer risk - Information-Analytic Agency NEWS.am - November 2nd, 2019
- Talking to Your Teen About Vaping: Here's What Parents Should Know - Health Essentials from Cleveland Clinic - November 2nd, 2019
- Think You Don't Need Air Purifiers And Anti-Pollution Masks? Research Says Otherwise - News18 - November 2nd, 2019
- Heart Scan Market 2019 Global Industry Analysis By Size, Share, Opportunities, Growth, Emerging Technologies, And Regional Forecast To 2023 -... - November 2nd, 2019
- The Game Changers Film Hits Men Where It Hurts Most - CleanTechnica - November 2nd, 2019
- 7 Health Benefits of Kakadu Plum - Healthline - November 2nd, 2019
- Mom Takes On NYC Marathon for Son With Heart Disease Who Wont Be Able to Run One - Runner's World - October 30th, 2019
- More renewables will mean less asthma and heart disease in the Midwest - Energy News Network - October 30th, 2019
- New Intermountain Study Aims to Determine the Most Effective Method to Identify People at Risk for Heart Disease Before They Ever Develop Problems -... - October 30th, 2019
- Facebook Preventive Health leads with cancer and heart disease - - pharmaphorum - October 30th, 2019
- Firefighters Checking Smoke Alarms and Blood Pressure: HOPE 4 - Medscape - October 30th, 2019
- Ingredients for Heart Health on the Rise Due to Rising Health Consciousness - vegconomist - the vegan business magazine - October 30th, 2019
- These are the most surprising causes of death in all 50 states: report - Fox Business - October 30th, 2019
- Is A Diet That's Healthy For Us Also Better For The Planet? Most Of The Time, Yes - NPR - October 30th, 2019
- New Alzheimer Treatment Could Take The Brakes Off The Bodys Repair Systems Allowing It To Repair Itself - Forbes - October 30th, 2019
- A Major Threat to Our Economy Health Care Spending - Heritage.org - October 30th, 2019
- Facebook creeps into the digital healthcare industry - Digital Information World - October 30th, 2019
- New BHF investment to boost heart and circulatory disease research at University of Birmingham - University of Birmingham - October 30th, 2019
- Appalachians Are Dying At Higher Rates Than Most Americans; Investing In Education Could Change That - West Virginia Public Broadcasting - October 30th, 2019
- Town Hall Meeting Zeroes in on Legislation for Memory Loss Disease - NewsRadio 560 KPQ - KPQ - October 30th, 2019
- Study: Women With Bulimia Nervosa Face Higher Risk of Cardiovascular Disease - The Swaddle - October 30th, 2019
- Night shifts can put you at risk of heart diseases, cancer and more - TheHealthSite - October 30th, 2019
- Gigantic study reveals the healthiest foods are the most sustainable - Inverse - October 30th, 2019
- People with mental disorders have higher risk of early death - Futurity: Research News - October 30th, 2019
- Doctors call on workplaces to ban sale of sugary drinks - The Guardian - October 30th, 2019
- DOH eyes increasing taxes on salty products - ABS-CBN News - October 30th, 2019
- Gap in care found for patients with chronic kidney disease: study - Folio - University of Alberta - October 30th, 2019
- Surgeries of children with heart defects to commence shortly at NICVD Tando Muhammad Khan - The News International - October 30th, 2019
- The 9 Healthiest Types of Juice - Healthline - October 30th, 2019
- Global Congenital Heart Diseases Market Analysis by Industry Share, Types, Region and Overview 2025 - TheNewsWire24 - October 30th, 2019