The UK governments chief scientific adviser, Patrick Vallance (L) and chief medical officer, Chris Whitty, en route to a Cobra meeting in Whitehall. Photograph: Dominic Lipinski/PA
Experts have voiced growing frustration over the UK governments claim that it is following the science, saying the refrain is being used to abdicate responsibility for political decisions.
They also raised concerns that the views of public health experts were being overlooked, with disproportionate weight given to the views of modellers.
As a scientist, I hope I never again hear the phrase based on the best science and evidence spoken by a politician, Prof Devi Sridhar, chair of global public health at the University of Edinburgh, told the Guardian. This phrase has become basically meaningless and used to explain anything and everything.
The government has repeatedly said it is being led by the science on decisions ranging from banning mass gatherings to closing schools, the use of face masks and, most recently, the prospects of lifting the lockdown.
However, Sridhar and others argued that scientific views on these topics could be wide-ranging and dependent on a scientists field of expertise.
The diversity of scientific views was apparent in March when case numbers were rising rapidly but the government chose not to ban mass gatherings or introduce wide-reaching physical distancing.
World Health Organization advice, and what weve learned from lots of previous outbreaks in low- and middle-income countries, is that the faster you move at the start, the better, because its exponential growth, Sridhar said. In public health, a test, trace and isolate campaign wouldve been where your mind first went.
Instead, she said, the government appeared to be basing policy on the presumption of a binary choice between two scenarios, played out in computer models, of either eradicating the virus or it becoming endemic.
Prof Mark Woolhouse, an infectious diseases epidemiologist at the University of Edinburgh, said modelling had had a disproportionate influence. I do think scientific advice is driven far too much by epidemiology and Im an epidemiologist.
What were not talking about in the same formal, quantitative way are the economic costs, the social costs, the psychological costs of being under lockdown, he said. I understand that the government is being advised by economists, psychiatrists and others, but were not seeing what that science is telling them. I find that very puzzling.
Woolhouse said that while it was understandable that saving lives was the top priority, the idea of doing this at any cost was naive.
With any disease there is a trade-off. Public health is largely about that trade-off. Whats happening here is that both sides of the equation are so enormous and so damaging that the routine public health challenge of balancing costs and benefits is thrown into incredibly stark relief. Yet that balance has to be found.
Others expressed concern about the lack of transparency around the evidence affecting decision-making. We dont know who sits on Sage [the governments scientific advisory group for emergencies], we see very little of the papers that go to Sage, said Prof Sheila Bird, the former programme leader of the Medical Research Councils biostatistics unit at the University of Cambridge. That scientific underpinning is not evident.
Sridhar said the failure to fully consider the perspectives of experts beyond epidemiology may have contributed to misguided decisions. Models appear not to have factored in the role of hospital staff shortages, which may have diverted attention from the urgent need for adequate personal protective equipment, she said.
The concept of shielding the most vulnerable looks beautiful in models, she said, but in reality care homes are facing major outbreaks and multigenerational households are struggling to isolate the vulnerable. You cant take these people out of the system and isolate them as if they were a data point on a graph, she said.
Theres a real problem if you have a collection of people from the same background, the same field, the same institutions; that can lead to blindspots and groupthink, Sridhar added. Diversity is clearly important for better decision-making.
Some fear the prominence given to science in supporting political decisions risks burdening scientists with unrealistic expectations and could ultimately erode trust in their expertise.
The government isnt using expertise simply to validate claims, it also appears to be using it as an insurance policy, Prof Christina Boswell, a political scientist at the University of Edinburgh, wrote this week. If things go wrong and the curve gets too steep it will be the scientific advice that is to blame.
Prof Chris Whitty: the truthtellerChief medical officers have a tradition of speaking their mind, often to the chagrin of governments. Whitty, however, has appeared to be in perfect harmony with the UK government at the Downing Street briefings on Covid-19. The reality is probably that ministers are in step with him or even a step behind. On Wednesday, Whitty, a practising NHS consultant physician, told a starker truth than politicians have dared: that physial distancing needs to be in place until at least the end of the year.
Sir Patrick Vallance: the political naifVallance has had a career in medicine at University College London and St Georges, University of London, researching vascular biology and endothelial cell physiology, and also in the pharmaceutical industry. From 2012 to 2018, he was president of research and development at GlaxoSmithKline, where, unusually for the industry, he advocated greater openness about innovation and partnerships with other companies.
He left to become the governments chief scientific adviser, but is not an instinctive politician. He was partly blamed for the governments flirtation with the notion of herd immunity, saying in March that the strategy was to reduce the peak, not suppress it completely. Also, because the vast majority of people get a mild illness, to build up some kind of herd immunity so more people are immune to this disease. Afterwards it was denied he meant herd immunity should be the goal; it was simply an outcome.
Neil Ferguson: the workaholicFerguson leads the modelling behind the UK response through the MRC Centre for Global Infectious Disease Analysis, which he founded with colleagues at Imperial College. He has a long history in modelling epidemics, originally with Roy Andersons unit at Oxford University, where they worked on BSE, vCJD, foot and mouth, Sars and swine flu sometimes attracting controversy.
Ferguson is a mathematician, an epidemiologist and a workaholic who, before the lockdown, moved seamlessly between Downing Street, university and press briefings. Even while recovering from Covid-19 himself, he gave evidence to MPs and did interviews. His teams work is at the heart of the lockdown strategy, predicting the numbers of deaths it will save.
Dr Jenny Harries: the national treasure
The deputy chief medical officer has been called a national treasure by Vogue, which may reflect the fact she is a rarity a woman on the Downing Street briefings podium. With degrees in pharmacology and medicine, she joined Public Health England in 2013. Like her boss, Whitty, she is independent-minded, and she warned at the end of March that the lockdown could last for six months or longer. She also suggested couples living separately could test the strength of their relationship during the lockdown by moving in together.
Prof Jonathan Van-Tam: the flu expert
Jonathan Stafford Nguyen Van-Tam is a widely published expert on influenza and the vaccines and antiviral drugs used to treat it. Now one of the governments two deputy chief medical officers, he is regularly deferred to by Hancock. He spent four years in the pharmaceutical industry before returning to the public sector to head the pandemic influenza office of the Health Protection Agency, which is now part of Public Health England, and was a member of Sage during the 2009-10 swine flu pandemic. His grandfather Nguyn vn Tm was the prime minister of Vietnam in 1952.
Prof Stephen Powis: the NHSs defender
A kidney specialist, Powis is a professor of renal medicine at UCL and was the medical director of the Royal Free hospital until 2018. Now the medical director of NHS England, his job is to defend it against the threat of Covid-19. As such, his comments at Downing Street briefings have not always stuck to the medical need. With Michael Gove on 4 April, he criticised people sabotaging 5G phone masts under the illusion they were implicated in the spread of the virus. Im absolutely outraged, absolutely disgusted, that people would be taking action against the very infrastructure that we need to respond to this health emergency, he said.
Read more from the original source:
Scientists criticise UK government's 'following the science' claim - The Guardian
- Vascular Cell and Molecular Biology | Center for Vascular Biology | Weill Cornell ... - April 13th, 2018 [April 13th, 2018]
- APVBO-Asia Pacific Vascular Biology Organization Conference - April 18th, 2018 [April 18th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology Conferences | Vascular Surgery ... - May 5th, 2018 [May 5th, 2018]
- Vascular Discovery: From Genes to Medicine - May 7th, 2018 [May 7th, 2018]
- 2019 Vascular Cell Biology Conference GRC - May 26th, 2018 [May 26th, 2018]
- Biology 211: Taxonomy of Flowering Plants - June 7th, 2018 [June 7th, 2018]
- esm-evbo2019.org - Menu - July 27th, 2018 [July 27th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology | Pulmonary, Allergy, Sleep & Critical ... - November 16th, 2018 [November 16th, 2018]
- Lower vascular plant | biology | Britannica.com - November 18th, 2018 [November 18th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology - NAVBO - November 20th, 2018 [November 20th, 2018]
- 2019 Cerebral Vascular Biology Conference - cvent.com - November 21st, 2018 [November 21st, 2018]
- PPARs and Their Emerging Role in Vascular Biology ... - November 26th, 2018 [November 26th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology Chicago Medicine - November 30th, 2018 [November 30th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology | Society for Vascular Surgery - November 30th, 2018 [November 30th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology 2018 - NAVBO - December 19th, 2018 [December 19th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology 2019 - NAVBO - December 20th, 2018 [December 20th, 2018]
- Vascular Biology - January 22nd, 2019 [January 22nd, 2019]
- pvb2019.org Plant Vascular Biology Conference 2019 - January 31st, 2019 [January 31st, 2019]
- Plant Physiology | Basic Biology - March 12th, 2019 [March 12th, 2019]
- Awards - esm-evbo2019.org - April 23rd, 2019 [April 23rd, 2019]
- Medication and Exercise to Prevent Muscle Loss - Next Avenue - September 24th, 2019 [September 24th, 2019]
- A Snail as Fast as a Bullet, and Other Darwin-Defying Marvels - Discovery Institute - September 24th, 2019 [September 24th, 2019]
- Nature up close: Life in the Humboldt Penguin National Reserve - CBS News - September 24th, 2019 [September 24th, 2019]
- Oklahoma new hires and promotions announced - Oklahoman.com - September 24th, 2019 [September 24th, 2019]
- Quinn Capers IV, MD - TCTMD - September 24th, 2019 [September 24th, 2019]
- Cardiovascular Repair And Reconstruction Devices Market Global Industry Insights by Top Vendors, Growth, Revenue and Forecast Outlook 2019-2025 -... - September 26th, 2019 [September 26th, 2019]
- Four health projects at Boston Childrens Hospital that could help adults - The Boston Globe - September 30th, 2019 [September 30th, 2019]
- Research Officer/ Postdoctoral Researcher - The Conversation AU - October 16th, 2019 [October 16th, 2019]
- UNSW skin cancer researcher Levon Khachigian hit with string of retractions - ABC News - October 16th, 2019 [October 16th, 2019]
- Michal Wszola: We Expect to Transplant the Bioprinted Bionic Pancreas in Three to Five Years - 3DPrint.com - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- 'The Blob': This mysterious 'smart' slime can solve puzzles and make decisions - CNBC - October 24th, 2019 [October 24th, 2019]
- University of Maryland and DOD collaborate to study Tick-borne Infections using 3-D models of human blood vessels - Outbreak News Today - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- Submerged Vegetation Mirrors Coast's Health - Coastal Review Online - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- Another health warning for e-cigarette users that has nothing to do with lung disease - MarketWatch - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- E-Cigarettes Take a Dangerous Toll on Heart Health - DocWire News - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- Vascular biology Department of Surgery College of ... - November 19th, 2019 [November 19th, 2019]
- US Nobel laureates tell us what they think about cancer research, moonshots, the dark side, funding, meritocracy, herd mentality, Trump, and joy - The... - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Growing Organs in the Lab: One Step Closer to Reality - BioSpace - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Inotrem Announces Enrollment of First Patient in its Phase IIb ASTONISH Trial for Nangibotide in the Treatment of Septic Shock - Business Wire - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Another Study Suggests E-cigarettes Hurt Heart Health More Than Regular Cigarettes - Science Times - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- Cleveland Clinic awarded $12 million by NIH to study the link between gut microbes and heart disease - Crain's Cleveland Business - November 21st, 2019 [November 21st, 2019]
- JanOne Acquires Worldwide, Exclusive License for Promising Treatment of Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAD) - Yahoo Finance - November 27th, 2019 [November 27th, 2019]
- Germ-free lungs of newborn mice are partially protected against hyperoxia - The Mix - November 27th, 2019 [November 27th, 2019]
- Bethesda Health Physician Group Welcomes Fellowship-Trained Endocrine Surgeon Jessica L. Buicko, MD, to Its Team - The Boca Raton Tribune - November 27th, 2019 [November 27th, 2019]
- 9 Harvard researchers named AAAS Fellows Harvard - Harvard Gazette - November 27th, 2019 [November 27th, 2019]
- Top Technical Advances of 2019 - The Scientist - December 29th, 2019 [December 29th, 2019]
- Growing up Tyrannosaurus rex: Osteohistology refutes the pygmy Nanotyrannus and supports ontogenetic niche partitioning in juvenile Tyrannosaurus -... - January 2nd, 2020 [January 2nd, 2020]
- UCC currently taking applicants for 21 jobs with some incredible pay - Cork Beo - January 2nd, 2020 [January 2nd, 2020]
- Vascular Biology | Surgery Research | Michigan Medicine ... - January 2nd, 2020 [January 2nd, 2020]
- Sandy Bottom wetlands to receive protection for 'national ecological significance' - Citizen Times - January 14th, 2020 [January 14th, 2020]
- Why biotech is a boon for patients and investors - Spear's WMS - January 14th, 2020 [January 14th, 2020]
- Exonate Announces Collaboration With Janssen to Develop a New Eye Drop for the Treatment of Retinal Vascular Diseases Including Wet Age-related... - January 14th, 2020 [January 14th, 2020]
- G-protein Coupled Receptor Market Competitive Research And Precise Outlook 2019 To 2025 Dagoretti News - Dagoretti News - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]
- Scientists revealed the oldest known scorpion on Earth - Tech Explorist - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]
- How biology creates networks that are cheap, robust, and efficient - Penn: Office of University Communications - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]
- Genome editing heralds new era of disease research, therapy - The Augusta Chronicle - January 18th, 2020 [January 18th, 2020]
- Research Fellow in Vascular Stem Cell Biology job with QUEENS UNIVERSITY BELFAST | 195527 - Times Higher Education (THE) - February 10th, 2020 [February 10th, 2020]
- More than skin deep: the latest innovation in 3D printing - Med-Tech Innovation - February 10th, 2020 [February 10th, 2020]
- Examining the link between menopause and heart disease risk - Medical News Bulletin - February 10th, 2020 [February 10th, 2020]
- Women Face an Increased Risk of Heart Disease With AgeRunning Can Help - runnersworld.com - February 12th, 2020 [February 12th, 2020]
- G-protein Coupled Receptor Market Competitive Research And Precise Outlook 2019 To 2025 - Galus Australis - February 15th, 2020 [February 15th, 2020]
- Valentine's Day Matters of the Heart, Biopharma-Style - BioSpace - February 15th, 2020 [February 15th, 2020]
- The Addicted Gardener: Environmental tidbits from around the world - Wicked Local Sharon - February 22nd, 2020 [February 22nd, 2020]
- UI at 150 & Beyond: 'The Quad was the best no matter what the weather' - Champaign/Urbana News-Gazette - February 22nd, 2020 [February 22nd, 2020]
- The Addicted Gardener: Environmental tidbits from around the world - Wicked Local Dedham - February 23rd, 2020 [February 23rd, 2020]
- THE ADDICTED GARDENER: Environmental tidbits from around the world - Wicked Local Wareham - March 22nd, 2020 [March 22nd, 2020]
- 'Little Foot' skull reveals how this more than 3 million year old human ancestor lived - HeritageDaily - March 22nd, 2020 [March 22nd, 2020]
- It's Not Only About Neurons - The Good Men Project - March 22nd, 2020 [March 22nd, 2020]
- Who is Sir Patrick Vallance and what is his role in government during coronavirus outbreak? - The Scottish Sun - March 22nd, 2020 [March 22nd, 2020]
- University of Washington Pathology Professor Dies of COVID-19 - The Scientist - March 22nd, 2020 [March 22nd, 2020]
- THE ADDICTED GARDENER: Environmental tidbits from around the world - Wicked Local Rochester - March 23rd, 2020 [March 23rd, 2020]
- Ancient human ancestor 'Little Foot' probably lived in trees, new research finds - WBAP News/Talk - March 23rd, 2020 [March 23rd, 2020]
- Study shows similarity in anti-VEGF injection intervals for wet AMD - Ophthalmology Times - March 25th, 2020 [March 25th, 2020]
- aTyr Pharma and its Hong Kong Subsidiary, Pangu BioPharma, Announce Government Grant to Fund Bispecific Antibody Development Platform - BioSpace - March 25th, 2020 [March 25th, 2020]
- Health researchers find solution to life-threatening side effect - Mirage News - March 25th, 2020 [March 25th, 2020]
- European Vascular Biology Organisation | Advancing human ... - March 25th, 2020 [March 25th, 2020]
- Vascular Biology Program | Boston Children's Hospital - March 25th, 2020 [March 25th, 2020]
- Vascular Biology Research Program | Johns Hopkins ... - March 25th, 2020 [March 25th, 2020]
- Anatomy of a heatwave: how Antarctica recorded a 20.75C day last month - The Conversation AU - April 1st, 2020 [April 1st, 2020]
- Who is Sir Patrick Vallance and is he speaking at todays government coronavirus press briefing? - The Sun - April 1st, 2020 [April 1st, 2020]